Who Gets What? Division of Matrimonial Assets in a Singapore Divorce

In Singapore, splitting assets in a divorce is governed by section 112 of the Women’s Charter 1961. The court divides the matrimonial assets in the proportions it considers “just and equitable”, which is not an automatic 50/50 split, after weighing each spouse’s financial and non-financial contributions to the marriage. The outcome depends on your specific facts, so please consult a qualified lawyer.

Where both spouses have worked, the Court of Appeal’s structured approach in ANJ v ANK [2015] SGCA 34 is the starting point: the court averages each spouse’s direct and indirect contributions and then adjusts that average for the circumstances of the marriage. Where one spouse was the sole earner in a long marriage, a different line of cases applies. Both are explained below.

What counts as a matrimonial asset

Section 112(10) of the Women’s Charter defines a “matrimonial asset” in two parts:

  • Assets acquired during the marriage by one or both spouses, of any nature: property, bank balances, CPF savings, shares, insurance policies with cash value, vehicles and business interests.
  • Assets acquired before the marriage by one or both spouses that were either (i) ordinarily used or enjoyed by both spouses or their children while living together, for shelter, transportation, household, education, recreational, social or aesthetic purposes, or (ii) substantially improved during the marriage by the other spouse or by both spouses.

The definition then excludes one category: an asset acquired by one spouse at any time by gift or inheritance, which has not been substantially improved during the marriage by the other spouse or by both spouses. This exclusion does not apply to a matrimonial home. A flat or house that one spouse inherited or received as a gift, and that became the family home, is part of the pool.

In USB v USA [2020] SGCA 57, the Court of Appeal explained how these rules work together:

Type of assetEnters the pool for division?
Acquired during the marriage (not a gift or inheritance)Yes
Acquired before the marriageOnly if ordinarily used by the family as described in s 112(10), or substantially improved during the marriage by the other spouse or both spouses
Gift or inheritance, whenever receivedOnly if it is the matrimonial home, or substantially improved during the marriage by the other spouse or both spouses
Matrimonial homeYes, however and whenever it was acquired

Two further points from USB v USA matter in practice. First, “substantially improved” requires “the investment of money or money’s worth”, such as paid renovation works; a rise in market value on its own is not an improvement. Second, once a pre-marriage asset or gift is transformed into a matrimonial asset, its whole value enters the pool, not only the part attributable to the marriage.

Which date counts? In ARY v ARX [2016] SGCA 13, the Court of Appeal held that the starting point for identifying which assets are in the pool is the date of Interim Judgment. The court can depart from that date for good reason, for example where one spouse has unfairly depleted the assets.

Whether a particular asset falls inside or outside the pool turns on its history, so documents that trace where the money came from (purchase records, bank statements, the will or deed of gift) are important.

What the court considers when splitting assets: section 112(2)

Section 112(2) of the Women’s Charter requires the court to have regard to all the circumstances of the case, including:

  1. the contributions each spouse made in money, property or work towards acquiring, improving or maintaining the matrimonial assets;
  2. any debt or obligation either spouse incurred for their joint benefit or for the benefit of a child of the marriage;
  3. the needs of the children of the marriage;
  4. each spouse’s contributions to the welfare of the family, including looking after the home or caring for the family or an aged or infirm relative or dependant;
  5. any agreement between the spouses on the ownership and division of the matrimonial assets made in contemplation of divorce;
  6. any period of rent-free occupation or other benefit one spouse enjoyed in the matrimonial home to the exclusion of the other;
  7. assistance or support one spouse gave the other, material or not, including help that aided the other’s occupation or business; and
  8. the matters in section 114(1), so far as relevant, such as each spouse’s income, earning capacity, financial needs, age and the length of the marriage.

Factors 1 and 4 are the “direct” and “indirect” contributions that the structured approach below turns into percentages. Section 114 itself deals with spousal and child maintenance, which the court decides separately from the division of assets.

The structured approach in ANJ v ANK [2015] SGCA 34

The Court of Appeal in ANJ v ANK [2015] SGCA 34 set out a structured approach for the general run of cases:

  1. Direct contributions. The court assigns each spouse a percentage for their financial contributions to acquiring or improving the matrimonial assets: purchase price, mortgage instalments, renovation costs and similar payments that can be traced to that spouse.
  2. Indirect contributions. The court assigns each spouse a percentage for their contributions to the family’s well-being, both financial (household expenses, school fees, utilities) and non-financial (caregiving, homemaking, supporting the other’s career).
  3. Average and adjust. The court averages the two percentages. It may give more weight to one of them depending on the marriage: indirect contributions carry more weight in a long marriage; direct contributions may carry more weight where the pool is exceptionally large and was built through one spouse’s exceptional efforts; and the weight of homemaking contributions may be lower where the family relied heavily on a domestic helper.

The result is each spouse’s percentage share of the net pool.

Hypothetical example (for illustration only, not a real case). Suppose the court assesses direct contributions at 70% (husband) and 30% (wife), and indirect contributions at 30% (husband) and 70% (wife) because the wife reduced her working hours to care for the children. The simple average is 50% each. The court then decides whether the facts justify giving more weight to either ratio before fixing the final split.

Single-income and dual-income marriages: TNL v TNK and TQU v TQT

In TNL v TNK [2017] SGCA 15, the Court of Appeal held that the structured approach should not be applied to single-income marriages, where one spouse was the sole earner and the other the homemaker. Applying it there would count the earning spouse’s financial contributions twice, once as direct contributions and again as part of the indirect contributions. The court observed that in long single-income marriages, the precedents tend towards an equal division of the matrimonial assets.

Whether a marriage is “single-income” depends on the facts. In TQU v TQT [2020] SGCA 8, the wife argued that hers was a long single-income marriage. The Court of Appeal disagreed because both spouses had worked in the family’s clinic during the marriage and neither had been a full-time homemaker until the clinic closed, so the structured approach applied.

If you stepped back from paid work to raise the children, do not assume either approach applies automatically. The court looks at the pattern of work and income across the whole marriage.

How specific assets are split: HDB, CPF, property, business and investments

The same section 112 principles apply to every asset, but each type raises its own practical questions.

The HDB flat

An HDB flat that is the family home is a matrimonial asset. The court may order that one spouse keeps it, that one spouse’s share is transferred to the other, or that the flat is sold and the proceeds divided (section 112(5)). HDB’s rules decide which option works in practice: the spouse keeping the flat must meet HDB’s eligibility conditions, and an open-market sale is possible only once the Minimum Occupation Period has been met. For the detail, see our guide to dividing the matrimonial home: HDB vs private property rules, and on buying another flat after divorce, divorce and BTO flats.

CPF savings

CPF savings built up during the marriage are matrimonial assets. According to the CPF Board, the court can order either:

  • a transfer order, moving savings from one spouse’s CPF accounts to the other’s (the receiving spouse must be a Singapore Citizen or Permanent Resident); or
  • a charging order, under which the receiving spouse is paid in cash, possible only where the paying spouse is 55 or above and eligible to withdraw.

Since 19 January 2025, the Special Account of members aged 55 and above has been closed, and no transfer can be made from it. Where CPF savings were used for a property, check how much each spouse must refund to their own CPF account on a sale or transfer. The CPF Board publishes suggested wording for court orders on its division of CPF assets page.

Private property

Condominiums and landed property follow the same section 112 analysis, without HDB’s eligibility rules. Mortgage payments, renovation costs and rental income during the marriage count towards direct contributions, and a property bought before the marriage that the family lived in is part of the pool.

Business interests in a Pte Ltd

Shares acquired during the marriage are matrimonial assets. Shares held before the marriage are included only if the other spouse, or both spouses, substantially improved the business during the marriage, and then their whole value is included (USB v USA [2020] SGCA 57). Valuation is then the central question. The court can let the owning spouse keep the business and order a payment or a larger share of other assets to the other spouse (section 112(5)). See divorce for business owners.

Investments, savings and insurance

Bank balances, shares and unit trusts acquired during the marriage are divided like other assets, in cash or in kind. Insurance policies count up to their surrender or cash value; term policies with no cash value are not divided.

Assets held overseas

Matrimonial assets are not limited to those in Singapore. Property, bank accounts and investments held abroad form part of the pool and must be disclosed. Enforcing an order over foreign property may need steps under the law where it is located.

Are debts split in a divorce?

Section 112(2)(b) directs the court to consider any debt or obligation a spouse incurred for the couple’s joint benefit or for a child of the marriage. A housing loan still owing on the matrimonial home, for example, is relevant to the value of that asset to the couple, and a debt taken on for the family is viewed differently from one a spouse ran up for purely personal purposes. For a closer look at credit cards, personal loans and guarantees, see what happens to shared debts when you get divorced.

Pre- and post-nuptial agreements: how much weight do they carry?

An agreement on the division of assets made in contemplation of divorce is one of the matters the court must consider (section 112(2)(e)). It does not take assets out of the pool, and the court keeps its discretion. An agreement carries more weight where both spouses had independent legal advice and full financial disclosure, and where the terms protect the children and leave neither spouse in hardship. See our page on pre-nuptial and post-nuptial agreements.

Hidden assets, non-disclosure and misconduct

Each spouse must give full and frank disclosure of their assets. Where a spouse fails to disclose assets or explain where money went, the court can draw an adverse inference. In TQU v TQT [2020] SGCA 8, the husband did not account for returns from properties he had disposed of, and the Court of Appeal adjusted the division by 10 percentage points in the wife’s favour to reflect this. If you suspect assets are being concealed, see how to uncover your spouse’s hidden assets.

Misconduct in the marriage, such as adultery, is not one of the section 112(2) factors, and the division is based on contributions rather than fault. The court can ascribe a negative value to a spouse’s contributions, but in TQU v TQT the Court of Appeal said the threshold is high: the conduct must be both extreme and undisputed, and must fundamentally undermine the marriage partnership.

Protecting your asset position before and during divorce

  • Collect statements for bank accounts, CPF, shares, insurance and property early.
  • Avoid large, unexplained transfers or withdrawals. The court can adjust the division where assets have been unfairly depleted (ARY v ARX [2016] SGCA 13).
  • If your spouse is disposing of assets to defeat your claim, the court can grant an injunction or set aside a disposition made in the 3 years before the application, under section 139M of the Women’s Charter (in force since 16 January 2025). See also protecting your assets in case of a divorce.

How the split is decided in the divorce process

The division of assets is an ancillary matter, decided at the second stage of the divorce after the court has granted Interim Judgment. Spouses who agree on how to split their assets can record the terms in a consent order, which is the route in an uncontested divorce and in a divorce by mutual agreement. Where they cannot agree, each spouse files affidavits disclosing their assets and the court decides at an ancillary matters hearing, as in a contested divorce.

Under section 112(5), the orders the court can make include:

  • selling an asset and dividing the proceeds;
  • vesting an asset, or part of it, in one spouse;
  • holding an asset on trust, or postponing its sale, until a set date or event (for example, until the youngest child reaches a certain age);
  • giving one spouse the right to occupy the matrimonial home to the exclusion of the other for a period; and
  • ordering one spouse to pay a sum of money to the other, in one sum or in instalments.

For how the two stages fit together from filing to Final Judgment, see our guide to the divorce process in Singapore.

Frequently asked questions

Is splitting assets in a divorce always 50/50 in Singapore?

No. Section 112(1) requires a just and equitable division, not an equal one. In dual-income marriages the court applies the structured approach in ANJ v ANK [2015] SGCA 34; in long single-income marriages, the precedents tend towards an equal division (TNL v TNK [2017] SGCA 15).

Does adultery affect how assets are split?

Adultery is not one of the factors in section 112(2); the split is based on contributions. The court can give a negative value to a spouse’s contributions only where the conduct is extreme and undisputed (TQU v TQT [2020] SGCA 8). Hiding or depleting assets is dealt with separately, through an adverse inference or an adjustment.

Can a pre-nuptial agreement override section 112?

No. Under section 112(2)(e) the court must have regard to it, and a well-prepared agreement with independent advice and full disclosure can carry significant weight, but the court keeps its discretion.

How long does the asset-division stage take?

It depends on whether the spouses agree. Agreed terms can be recorded in a consent order as part of the divorce. If the division is disputed, it is decided at an ancillary matters hearing after both spouses have filed affidavits of their assets, which takes longer. The divorce process guide explains each stage.

Sources

The law and CPF rules in this article are stated as at September 2026.

If you are Muslim, the Administration of Muslim Law Act 1966 (AMLA) and the Syariah Court apply. This article covers civil divorce under the Women’s Charter only.

This article is for general information only and does not constitute legal advice. Please consult a qualified lawyer for advice on your specific situation.

7 Biggest Myths About Wills

Death is a taboo subject to many. Therefore, people choose to avoid discussion on the subject. However, the increasing number of deaths caused by the coronavirus pandemic globally has now brought home the possibility and fear of death to many people. With social distancing measures and lockdowns in place, you may find yourself having more time to plan for and focus on important and fundamental issues that matter to you. It may be an opportune time to prepare an estate plan if you do not already have one. A well thought out and properly executed estate plan will ensure that your loved ones are provided for when you are no longer around.

In this article, we address certain misconceptions about wills and why it is advisable and beneficial to seek the help and advice of a specialist trusts and estates legal professional to make your will.

1.  I am not wealthy and I do not have many assets, so it is not necessary for me to make a will.

You don’t need to have vast wealth to make a will.

A will ensures that your assets (regardless of value) are left to the persons whom you intend to receive these assets after you pass on.

In fact, vulnerable family members in less well-to-do households will benefit from a properly executed will as that ensures that they receive the financial support to continue with their lives after the breadwinner passes.

It is also common for Singaporeans to own their homes. Your home may well be worth at least half a million dollars, and its value will continue to grow as you age. Most Singaporeans may also have life insurance policies, which will, upon one’s passing, pay out anything from a few hundred thousand to even a million or more dollars.

It only takes a small investment of time and money to make a proper will to ensure that your assets (which may continue to grow over the years) to be properly distributed after you are gone. Moreover, after one’s death, distribution of assets if one has a will would be much faster, cost- effective and easier process compared to if one does not have a will.

2.  The law will provide for the distribution of my assets, so I do not need a will.

It is true that if you do not have a will, the state can provide for the distribution of your assets according to the Intestate Succession Act.

However, the intestacy laws may not be in accordance with your wishes, and can lead to the following unintended and undesirable consequences:

(a)  Some of your loved ones may be left out.

For example, if you are an adult in your late 30s or early 40s who is married with children, and if your parents are still alive at the time of your death, your parents will not receive any of your assets. Under intestacy laws, 50 per cent. of your assets will go to your spouse and the remainder 50 per cent. to your children. You would have to rely on the goodwill of your surviving spouse to take care of and maintain your parents, and that is assuming they got along when you were alive!

Another example is that if you are in a committed relationship but not married, your partner would receive nothing at all from your estate.

(b)  This may cause unhappiness amongst the family members.

While it is easy to divide monies in a bank account based on simple mathematics, family members may not see eye to eye when dividing personal possessions or immovable property. What does it mean to divide a property equally between all the surviving children? What happens if one sibling wishes to stay in the property with his wife and children, and the other wishes to sell the property. Would the former be required to pay rent to the other sibling, and if so, how much should the rent be? Alternatively, should he purchase his sibling’s share of the property, and what if he does not have the money to do so?

What about your jewellery and/or watches? Which child or relative should receive your diamond ring(s) or luxury watch(es)? Do you possess any paintings or carpets which may or may not have significant monetary value but of sentimental value to you?

The responses to these questions may not be straightforward, especially as relationships change and time passes.

If you have a preference as to how your assets should be distributed, it is important to make a will to ensure that your assets are distributed according to your wishes, and to make special provisions for your loved ones.

3.  I only have one child so there will not be any inheritance dispute.

A will allows you to state who should act as the guardian for your child in the event that you and your spouse die before your child turns 21. If you do not have a will, the decision could be left to the family courts, who may choose a person that you or your spouse may not agree with.

Additionally, some may feel that their child, despite being of legal age, may be too young to manage a potentially significant sum of money. To address that concern, a trustee (who can be a trusted family member or an unrelated third party) can be appointed in a will to hold and manage the assets for the child until the child reaches a certain age or milestone. For example, the trustee can be instructed to earmark a sum of money for the child’s further education or for the purchase of the child’s first home. Significant assets can also be released to the child after he or she turns 30, or assets can be distributed to the child on a yearly basis. This gives parents the peace of mind that there is some supervision and control over the way their child will use the inheritance.

4.  I have already distributed most of my wealth to my children in my lifetime.

Dividing up an estate can sadly lead to quarrels and damage relationships among your family members and can be expensive if the dispute escalates into protracted legal proceedings. In the absence of expressly written wishes, family members may have different interpretations of the actual intentions of a person who has passed away. Consider this illustration. You own 2 properties and have gifted your elder child one of these 2 properties in your lifetime. You co-own the second property with your younger child with the intention that, upon your passing, the property will be inherited by your younger child. These intentions may not have been made clear to both children and without a will, could remain unclear after your passing. Your elder child may have had a different expectation and may have thought that your (50 per cent.) share of the second property would be distributed equally to both children.

If friendly discussions fail, legal disputes may ensue between the children in future. This can be avoided if your intentions are made clear in a will.

5.  Wills are for the elderly.

We will never know for sure when and how we will pass on. A death can occur when we least expect it. Without a will, distribution of your assets may take many months, and sometimes even years if it is legally disputed. Meanwhile, your loved ones, especially young children and elderly parents, will have no means of supporting themselves.

Making a will is simply a tool to plan ahead for the inevitable, whenever it may arrive. It will give you peace of mind knowing that those close to you will be taken care of when you are no longer around.

6.  Making a will is complicated.

Some worry that making a will involves a full review of their finances and will take a long time to complete.

Depending on the size of your assets and the wishes you would like to make in your will, drawing up a will may only take a few days. The process usually requires a first meeting (or video- conference) where your legal adviser will discuss your needs with you and take your instructions, and a second meeting with your legal adviser to go through the final document and to sign it. Any other discussion on the contents of the will, if necessary, can take place by telephone call or e-mail.

You do not need to have all the latest details of your assets in order to prepare your will. All that is required is a broad idea of what your assets comprise so that your legal adviser can advise you accordingly. It is not necessary to produce evidence of your assets or a detailed breakdown of what you own.

7.  Making a will is expensive, so I would rather do it myself.

A poorly written will is at risk of being invalid if it does not meet all the legal requirements. In addition, if there is any ambiguity or contradictory information in the will, this causes uncertainty and opens the possibility for the will to be contested in court, incurring unnecessary legal costs and causing distress for your loved ones.

Aside from ensuring that legal requirements are met, an experienced trusts and estates lawyer will understand the nuances of drafting the will to prevent ambiguity and uncertainty and minimise the possibility of litigation risks in future. He or she will also be able to advise you on what a will can or cannot do, and the steps that you may have to take to put your affairs in order. This is because they can help to implement them after a client has passed away (which is part of the process of extracting the grant of probate under the Probate and Administration Act, which only lawyers can carry out).

Mistakes in a will can be costly and potentially disrupt family harmony. Therefore, it is not advisable for one to minimise costs in this area simply because of the availability of cheaper solutions elsewhere. Seeking advice from a specialist trusts and estates lawyer may cost more, but the result is a will that is tailored specially for your needs and not based on a standard template or formula.

As part of our estate planning practice, we regularly advise on and prepare wills for our clients to help them to manage and distribute their wealth. Our experience in contentious disputes, including mental capacity, probate and inheritance related disputes, gives us an advantage as we are able to anticipate possible risks. This enables us to advise you on how best to structure your estate plan to avoid future disputes down the road.

We believe that it is only by getting to know each individual and family, and understanding their background, wishes and relationships, can we advise on and prepare wills that ensure families and relationships are protected.

A will made with us will be personal to you, bespoke and tailored specially for your needs and concerns.

If you would like to discuss any of these further, please do get in touch with us.

Navigating the Process under the Probate and Administration Act

The loss of a loved one is always painful and often comes as a shock. With frequent exposure to news of tragedies and statistics, it’s easy to become desensitized to the numbers. Yet, for those who have experienced the death of a close friend or family member, this loss is deeply personal and profoundly real.

Dealing with the loss of a loved one is never easy. Adding to that, is the stress of having to deal quickly with the funeral arrangements and the distribution of the deceased’s assets in a short time after the deceased’s passing. This can be a very stressful and emotional period for most.

As experienced probate and estate administration lawyers, our goal is to guide our clients with a steady and supportive hand in managing their loved one’s estate during challenging and stressful times. If you are feeling uncertain after the passing of a loved one, we hope the insights shared in this article offer you some clarity on the steps to take next.

Find out if a Will was made.

As an immediate family member of the deceased, you may have an idea as to whether the deceased had made a Will in his or her lifetime, and the likely locations that the Will may be kept.

If you are aware that there is a Will, and have already located it, do make sure that you do not lose it. Keep it in a safe place and make copies of it. You would need the original Will to apply for a Grant of Probate.

If you know that the Deceased did not make a Will, this will mean that instead of applying for a Grant of Probate, you will be applying for a Grant of Letters of Administration.

If you are uncertain whether the deceased had made a Will, we would suggest conducting a thorough search of the deceased’s personal belongings, and any other likely places that the Will may be kept. It is also worthwhile to speak to other family members or close friends of the deceased to find out if the deceased had made a Will in his or her lifetime. Often, there are clues among one’s personal belongings that will hint at the possible existence of a Will. For example, one of our clients located a lawyer’s name card while rummaging through his late mother’s cabinet and this was helpful towards tracing the existence of the Will.

You could also conduct a search on the Wills Registry. While the Wills Registry does not hold a copy of the actual Will, it may point you towards persons or the law firm that has it (provided that the deceased had deposited this information with the Registry).

Who should distribute the Assets?

The person(s) in charge of distributing the Assets is/are called Executor(s) for Grant of Probate or Administrator(s) for Grant of Letter of Administration.

(a)  Where there is a valid Will, the Will should typically identify at least one Executor. Under the law, you can name up to four Executors in the Will. The Executor is responsible for distributing the deceased’s assets in accordance with the Will to the beneficiaries (the persons entitled to a share of the deceased’s estate).

(b)  But where there is no Will or if the deceased did not name the executor in his Will, it is important to decide who bears the responsibility to distribute the deceased’s assets. In other words, who is to be the Administrator of the deceased’s estate. Should it be the spouse of the deceased? A sibling of the deceased? One of the deceased’s children? Should it be the eldest child?

As each family’s situation is different, there is no right answer to this question. What a potential Administrator must note is that he or she may have to formally ask the other family members to give up or renounce their right to be an administrator if these family members are equal or higher in rank or priority. The way the renunciation can be made is found in Section 3 of the Probate and Administration Act.

The law specifies a ranking or priority system for persons entitled to apply for the Grant of Letters of Administration. This rank or priority is determined by the percentage or share of the deceased’s estate a person receives under the Intestate Succession Act (which only applies if the deceased died without a will). Simply put, the larger the share of estate you are entitled to, the higher in rank or priority you are.

There are many good reasons why a person of lower rank or priority should be the Administrator. One example is where the spouse of the deceased (who is entitled to a larger share) is alive but unable to practically administer the estate as he or she may be elderly. As the child of the deceased, you may be more mobile and be better placed to do so.

Identifying the Assets available for distribution

Banks, the Singapore Land Authority, HDB, as well as other financial and property related entities, would require the Executor or Administrator to be authorised by the Court and be given a copy of the Grant of Probate or the Grant of Letters of Administration, before allowing the transfer of the assets from the deceased to the beneficiaries.

A Schedule of Assets must accompany every Grant of Probate and Grant of Letter of Administration. Therefore, you will also need to know the details of all the deceased’s assets before making your application to Court. If you already have these details on hand, do take time to record them down. If you do not know the details of the deceased’s assets or suspect there are assets you are unaware of, you should take steps to find out.

If these assets are not listed in the Schedule of Assets, you would be unable to gain transfer, sell or deal with these assets, and will then have to go through the hassle of amending the Schedule subsequently to add the assets that have been missed in the original Schedule of Assets.

Once the Court has approved the application, you can then take the Grant of Probate or Grant of Letters of Administration and the accompanying Schedule of Assets to the various institutions where the deceased’s assets are kept.

Urgent Access to Funds

Last, there are situations where urgent access to funds in the deceased’s estate is necessary. For example, to pay for medical bills of deceased’s children or elderly parents. If urgent funds are required, you can choose to make an application first based on the assets of the deceased you know exist. The Schedule of Assets can be subsequently amended to reflect the other assets of the deceased you may discover later.

Do you need a lawyer to extract the Grant of Probate or Letters of Administration?

It is possible for you to obtain a Grant of Probate or Grant of Letters of Administration by yourself without engaging lawyers. The Family Justice Courts have published a very helpful and detailed Probate & Administration Toolkit, which can be found below.

However, this would mean that you would have to be very familiar with all the steps involved and be prepared to personally attend at various locations in order to get the Court documents prepared and filed in Court. Some of the things that you would be required to do include:

(1)  Recording all the details of all the assets of the deceased for Schedule of Assets. This may mean making numerous written queries or several trips to various institutions to find out the necessary information.

(2)  If applicable, obtain a renunciation from all other beneficiaries of equal or higher rank than you. This may be challenging if you may be estranged or have lost contact with some of them.

(3)  Engaging a Commissioner of Oaths to swear or affirm the Supporting Affidavit and the Administration Oath required to complete your application.

(4)  Attending in person at the LawNet & CrimsonLogic Service Bureau (located in Chinatown) at least twice to file the various documents and complete your application.

(5)  If one or more of the beneficiaries is a minor, you will also need to find two persons to give security in the amount of deceased’s estate and execute an Administration Bond. This is provided for under Section 29 of the Probate and Administration Act.

Given the number of steps involved, which you would naturally be unfamiliar with, it may further add to the stress you are currently experiencing to try and figure things out. The application process may take at least two to three months, and any errors may result in further delay in obtaining the Court’s approval of the paperwork.

Because of this, our clients usually prefer to engage us to assist them with this process. We will liaise with the financial institutions on your behalf, prepare the required Court documents, meet with you to answer any questions you may have and arrange for you to execute the documents before a Commissioner of Oaths. The entire process can be completed within 2-3 meetings and generally within 4 to 6 weeks.

The professional fees if the deceased’s estate is less than 3 million would usually be in the range of S$2,500 to S$3,500 (depending on the complexity of the matter) as we ensure that every step of the process is done and advised by lawyers, and not office managers or paralegals who are not qualified to give legal advice.

Dealing with the loss of a loved one is never easy and having to think about distribution of his or her assets is often the last thing on your mind. As lawyers experienced in probate and administration, you can have peace of mind leaving this matter in our hands.

In addition to our probate practice, we also regularly advise on and prepare wills for our clients to help them to manage and distribute their wealth. We are also experienced in contentious disputes, including mental capacity, probate and inheritance related disputes. Having an overview of the whole process gives us an advantage in anticipating potential challenges that may arise down the road.

If you would like to discuss any of these further, please do get in touch with us.

Children Caught In The Crossfire – Co-parenting During A Divorce

A divorce can have a lasting impact on a child’s life. During a divorce, a child may observe that his parents have gone from best friends to enemies that may no longer be on speaking terms. He may have to grapple with the breakdown of his family unit, and have to accept that spending time with both parents means shuttling between homes. Some children may witness constant fighting, and have also been used by their parents as messengers or pawns in the divorce battle. Needless to say, the way a divorce is handled can have different effects on a child.

Statistics show that more than 50 per cent. of young offenders or uncontrollable youths in Singapore come from families with separated or divorced parents.1

It is always helpful if a divorce takes place in as gentle a way as possible for the children involved, as how parents behave in such an exceptional situation will shape their children’s lives and how their children view relationships and marriage in future. In order to explore and work out a divorce process that is as easy as possible for their children and to minimise the adverse impact on their children, it is best for parents to put the children’s best interests above their own during the divorce.

We have set out below some practical suggestions for parents going through a divorce in Singapore.

1.  Understand divorce proceedings in Singapore and the key rules under the Women’s Charter

A divorce is essentially a dissolution (i.e termination) of the parties’ marital relationship. In Singapore, the law on divorce is found in the Women’s Charter. Save for exceptional circumstances, one’s marriage must have lasted at least 3 years before one is eligible for a divorce. In addition, either parent must be domiciled in Singapore at the time of commencement of the divorce proceedings or habitually resident in Singapore for at least 3 years before the commencement of the divorce proceedings.

A divorce can either be uncontested or contested. If parties agree that the marriage has broken down, and agree to the grounds for which the marriage has broken down, the divorce is uncontested. If not, the divorce is contested and a trial will be required at the Family Justice Courts to decide these issues.

Secondly, parties will have to agree on ancillary issues which are issues relating to the custody, care and control of, and access to, children, the division of matrimonial assets and the maintenance of the wife and children. Again, if these are not agreed, the Family Justice Courts will need to intervene and hearings will be required to decide these issues.

If any of the issues in the process is not agreed between divorcing parents with children under the age of 21, it is compulsory for the parents to attend a mandatory parenting programme mandated by the Ministry of Social and Family Development (the “Mandatory Parenting Programme”). The Mandatory Parenting Programme is a two-hour counselling session that aims to help parents to make better informed decisions in the divorce process which would focus on their children’s needs and interests.

2.  Have the correct attitude towards the divorce

It is important to begin the process of divorce with an appropriate mind-set. In our experience, couples going through a divorce are usually consumed with heartache and hurt. This can drive them to behave in an extremely acrimonious and conflict-driven manner. As a result, we have found that many of our clients have chosen to contest divorces in situations where, had they been able to set aside their emotions, they would not have contested.

In the process of advising such clients, we often talk through their motivations for contesting the divorce. Most are emotional reasons – dragging out the court proceedings in the hope that their spouse would have a change of heart, feeling bitter that their spouse has filed for the divorce first, or disagreeing on whose unreasonable behaviour it was that caused the breakdown in the marriage.

We have mentioned above that, if parties are not able to agree that a marriage has broken down, or on the grounds of marriage, then the Family Justice Courts would need to step in. This means that parties will have to undergo a trial, including a cross-examination of each party, to let the Family Justice Courts decide whether the marriage has indeed broken down, and the reasons why. This drags out the process and results in more time and legal costs. On the contrary, if parties can agree to the grounds of the divorce, this would save time and legal costs as a trial to determine these issues would not be necessary.

In Singapore, divorces are generally granted on a “no-fault” basis. This means that the Court will generally not take into account the reasons for the breakdown of marriage when deciding on ancillary matters, for example, in the division of matrimonial assets or when deciding on maintenance. Therefore, contesting the grounds of divorce to establish fault on the part of a spouse will not do much to help a party’s position when it comes to the ancillary matters.

It is rare for the Family Justice Courts to force parties to stay in a marriage when one has chosen to end it. Choosing to contest a divorce when you know that the marriage is over will only lead to protracting the legal proceedings, and increasing the pain inflicted on your family, including your children who will be caught in the middle.

3.  Seek proper legal representation – A lawyer cannot act for both husband and wife

To have a comprehensive understanding of your rights as parents, it is vital to seek full and proper legal advice.

Even if you and your spouse have decided to resolve the divorce amicably and to reach an agreement, it is still important for you to know your rights, and whether certain proposed access and/or maintenance terms are fair and reasonable. You should seek independent legal advice if you have any concerns with the proposed agreement.

While we would not suggest that one should drag out divorce proceedings unnecessarily, we would also caution against rushing into signing an agreement that has been prepared by your spouse’s lawyers especially if you have not been independently advised by a lawyer. In particular, do note that it is against legal professional rules for a lawyer to advise both husband and wife in matrimonial proceedings as this constitutes a conflict of interests.

Questions we typically receive from our matrimonial clients include:

  • What constitutes matrimonial assets that will be distributed?
  • What is a fair division of the matrimonial home and the assets especially if parties’ contributions are not equal?
  • Where should the child live after the divorce, and who pays for the child’s living and schooling expenses?
  • Can grandparents continue to take care of the child during the divorce?
  • What access arrangements would be more beneficial to the child?
  • If there is a third party in the picture, how do I ensure that my child is not affected by the presence of the third party?
  • If my spouse is a foreigner, how do I ensure that my spouse does not take my child away?
  • I am a foreigner and have a dependent pass. How do I ensure that my spouse does not cancel my dependent pass?
  • My spouse is verbally abusive to me in the presence of the child. How do I protect myself?

Each of the questions above can garner different answers, and each answer will have a direct impact on your child.

The facts of every case are different, which is why it is important for you to seek proper independent legal advice tailored to your circumstances, especially if you have found yourself asking one or more of these questions.

4.  Both parents should continue to have a presence in the child’s life

Research has shown that children have basic needs for healthy growth and development, and their parents will play a significant part in their development. However, time spent with a child is often limited for parents who are separated.

A parent’s access to a child is often limited as a result of divorce. Sometimes, this is due to one party deliberately attempting to limit the other party’s access to the child. Therefore, as parents, it is important when dealing with issues like access to a child, to look at such issues from the perspective of their children and recognise that children need both parents. With this in mind, perhaps parental conflict can be reduced and children can benefit as best as they can from a mutually agreed care and access arrangement.

To ensure that a child gets the best from both parents, the Family Justice Courts are empowered to make a broad range of access orders such as supervised access (where another party needs to be around), reasonable access or liberal access (i.e. no restrictions). As mentioned above, each case is different. You should seek valuable tailored advice on how custody, care and control and access would work in your specific situation.

5.  Divorce during a pandemic

We are living in unprecedented times, and have found that separated parents have had to make do with last minute changes to access arrangements. Parents should try to be a team in this situation, even if it is difficult. A divorce is already hard enough, let alone a divorce in the midst of a pandemic. Amidst all the fear and confusion surrounding the coronavirus pandemic, children are looking to their parents for support and reassurance.

For instance, if a party has moved out of the matrimonial home pending the conclusion of the divorce proceedings, there may be concerns with the child travelling between different households, especially during the Government’s Circuit Breaker.

We would suggest that this not be seen as an opportunity to deprive your child of speaking to or meeting your former spouse. Parents must learn to place the welfare and needs of their children before their own, and that means working well with the other party to make access arrangements that would give their child the greatest assurance of stability.

The learned Registrar Kenneth Yap of the Family Justices Courts has emphasised that parents should work jointly towards devising practical solutions for access and other child-related issues with the children’s best interests in mind, and should comply with all the Government’s Circuit Breaker measures. Talk through concerns with your spouse, and be open to new arrangements. Consider if other non-physical contact with the child could be implemented during this period, for example, pre-agreed and regular timings for telephone or video calls with the child so that the other parent continues to have contact (albeit remote) with the child. If you do not live with your child, accept that, sometimes, not physically meeting your child during this period may be a beneficial arrangement for the health and wellbeing of your child. We would also suggest that both parents take into account each other’s views and suggestions as to any proposals on parenting and home learning.

Custody and access arrangements that parents make in the next couple of weeks have an impact on the immediate safety and welfare of their children and families. In addition, the behaviour of parties during this period may also have a bearing on future custody and access arrangements. In general, the Family Justice Courts are usually more supportive of a parent who has endeavoured to make arrangements where the children’s interests and welfare are prioritised.

At Jacque Law LLC, we have many years of experience handling a wide range of matrimonial matters (including contested and uncontested divorces), and are therefore well-equipped to provide the appropriate advice to our clients. With adequate support and guidance, divorce proceedings do not have to be painful, and can often bring about peace, closure and positive change.

The Dummy’s Guide To Making A Lasting Power of Attorney

What is an LPA?

A Lasting Power of Attorney (“LPA”) is a legal instrument which allows a person who is at least 21 years of age (the “Donor”) to voluntarily appoint one or more persons (the “Donee(s)”) to make decisions and act on his/her behalf should he/she lose mental capacity one day.

Types of decisions that a Donee can make

A Donee can be appointed to make decisions for the Donor under two general categories, namely “Personal Welfare” and “Property and Affairs”. It is only when a Donor loses mental capacity that the Donee(s) will have the power, in general, to make decisions.

Personal Welfare decisions include:

(a)   where the Donor should live e.g. at home or in a nursing home;

(b)   whom the Donor should live with e.g. with the Donee or alone;

(c)   what medical treatments the Donor should undergo e.g. western medicine paired with complementary Traditional Chinese Medicine (TCM) or western medicine only, or elective surgical procedures; and

(d)   whom the Donor should meet with and what social activities he/she should engage in (if possible) e.g. chair yoga sessions for the elderly or ballroom dancing.

Property and Affairs decisions include:

(a)   dealing with the Donor’s property (i.e buying, selling, renting and/or mortgaging);

(b)   opening, closing and operating the Donor’s bank accounts;

(c)   handling the Donor’s tax matters; and

(d)   purchasing a vehicle or other equipment which the Donor may need.

By law, the Donee is prohibited from entering into certain decisions on behalf of the Donor. For example, the Donee cannot make decisions such as forcing a Donor to get married, changing the Donor’s religion or changing the particulars of the Donor’s CPF nomination.

LPA and POA are different legal instruments

LPAs are often confused with a Power of Attorney (“POA”). However, they are not the same legal instrument.

A POA is a legal instrument whereby a person (the “Grantor”) grants powers in favour of another person (the “Attorney-in-fact”) to act within the powers granted by the Grantor and to act on his behalf while the Grantor retains mental capacity. Once a Grantor loses his mental capacity, the POA will be deemed invalid.

On the other hand, an LPA will become effective only when a Donor loses his mental capacity.

Consider this scenario:

Mr Chan is a successful businessman who travels for business and is not always in Singapore. He has granted a POA in favour of his wife, Mrs Chan, in respect of the various commercial properties that he owns in Singapore. Over the years, Mrs Chan has helped him in the rental, sale and mortgage of these properties, and she liaises with the banks, mortgage brokers, and real estate agents on his behalf.

Unfortunately, Mr Chan suffered a stroke and has been in a coma for many weeks. Mrs Chan receives a call that a buyer has made an offer to purchase one of the commercial properties at a price far above valuation. She is keen but can no longer sell that property on Mr Chan’s behalf as Mr Chan no longer has mental capacity and therefore the POA is no longer valid.

If Mr Chan had issued an LPA and appointed Mrs Chan to deal with his commercial properties under his LPA, such LPA would come into effect now, and Mrs Chan can sell that property.

Types of LPAs

Currently, there are two forms of LPAs prescribed by the Singapore Government that one can use as a basis to prepare his / her LPA.

Form 1 LPA

This is commonly referred to as the Standard Version. The powers given to the Donee(s) are wide-ranging, and there are limited restrictions on the Donee’s powers. 98% of LPAs that are registered in Singapore are based on Form 1 LPA, which arguably grant very wide powers to donees.

Form 1 LPAs allow up to two Donees to be appointed and provide for the Donor to choose, in the instance two Donees are appointed, whether the Donees should make decisions jointly and/or severally. If a Donor wished for more checks and balances on a donee, then it would choose for Donees to act jointly (and not severally).

Anecdotal evidence suggests, however, that most LPAs provide for Donees to act on a joint and several basis, meaning that a Donee may make a decision on behalf of the donor or deal with the donor’s assets without consulting the other Donee. For example, in the event that the Donor loses mental capacity, a Donee needs only produce a medical report certifying the donor’s mental incapacity in order to access the Donor’s funds.

It can therefore be said that a Form 1 LPA grants free rein over the donor’s cash, property, and investments (akin to a ‘blank check’), and statistics from the U.S. and U.K.1 point to LPA misuse as one of the commonest forms or means of financial abuse of the elderly.

Therefore, elderly persons at greater risk of financial abuse, including those who live alone, are affluent, have heirs who are not savvy in managing wealth or are prone to any form of addiction, or who have poor familial relationships, should strongly consider utilising Form 2 LPAs.

Form 2 LPA

In general, this is a more customised LPA, which can be used if a Donor has more requirements to be included in his LPA (e.g. if he wishes to give specific powers to his Donee).

Form 2 LPA also allows a Donor to set various restrictions in the Donee’s powers that are not available under a Form 1 LPA. This is an additional safeguard to ensure that the Donee does not abuse the powers given to him/her, and that the moneys are meant to be used for the Donor’s best interest.

Examples include:

(a)   specifying that the moneys in a particular bank account (and not all bank accounts belonging to the Donor) can only be withdrawn for a particular purpose, such as, for the payment of the Donor’s medical bills; and

(b)   specifying that the Donor does not wish to be placed in a nursing home, and that a sum of money is ear-marked for private nursing care in the Donor’s home.

Form 2 LPAs are also more suitable for business owners who may wish to appoint a Donee to specifically deal with company related affairs, but have no powers to deal with the Donor’s personal financial affairs.

Returning to the earlier factual scenario concerning the Chan Family:

Mr Chan is also one of the directors and shareholders of an SME company in the food & beverage industry. The company has been badly affected by COVID-19, and the board of directors are deciding whether the company should close some of its branches, and if so, which branches.

At the directors’ meeting, the directors are aware that Mr Chan has registered a Form 1 LPA and appointed Mrs Chan as his donee in respect of both personal welfare and property affairs decisions. Thus, Mrs Chan has the power to make decisions on behalf of Mr Chan as a director or shareholder of the company. As Mrs Chan is not familiar with the affairs of the company, she is unable to participate meaningfully in the discussions with the other directors.

A Form 2 LPA would have allowed Mr Chan to identify more than 2 Donees, and to allocate specific powers to these Donees which are not restricted by the standard form template in a Form 1 LPA. Instead of appointing Mrs Chan, Mr Chan could have appointed a peer in the same industry as that company (who could be more capable in making business decisions for that company) to have the limited power of making specific decisions on his behalf as a director and shareholder of the company.

Concluding Remarks

Having recently acted for a client in an acrimonious mental capacity dispute, we cannot emphasise the importance of planning ahead, and setting in place safeguards to ensure that in the event that we lose mental capacity, our assets and welfare will be protected by the people we trust, and decisions are executed in our best interests and in accordance with our wishes.

Protecting Your Assets In Case Of A Divorce

It is common to see a divorcing couple being unable to agree on how their assets should be split post-marriage, with differing accounts on how big-ticket items were financed before and during the marriage. This results in long, drawn-out court cases over the division of matrimonial assets, bringing much unhappiness to both parties and the people around them.

In this article, we aim to give an insight as to how both parties’ assets are split and divided post-marriage. Should you be looking to get married in the future or are currently married, this article aims to help you better understand the importance of forward planning, and what you should do now or avoid doing, in order to ensure that you obtain the best outcome for yourself in the unfortunate event of a breakdown of your marriage.

The division of a couple’s assets is generally done via two stages.

1. Stage 1: Firstly, all their assets are split into two categories: matrimonial assets (forming the “matrimonial pool”) or non-matrimonial assets.

2. Stage 2: Then, the assets in the matrimonial pool are divided amongst husband and wife according to a ratio / percentage determined by the Family Justice Courts.

In this article, we will be focusing on the first stage, the splitting of a couple’s assets into the matrimonial pool and the non-matrimonial pool.

To begin with, it is worth understanding that all assets (whether they are matrimonial assets or not) can be split into four classes of assets1

1. Quintessential matrimonial assets;

2. Transformed matrimonial assets;

3. Pre-marriage assets; and

4. Gifts and inherited assets.

One important factor which will be taken into account by the Family Justice Courts when deciding whether an asset goes into the matrimonial pool or not is the time at which it was acquired – whether it was before or after the marriage. However, this factor does not matter for assets categorised as “Gifts and inherited assets”. Thus, to begin with, we will be discussing the class of assets of Gifts and inherited assets.

Gifts and Inherited Assets

Generally, Gifts and Inherited assets will not go into the matrimonial pool, regardless of when these assets were acquired. Exceptions to this rule are if

1. the asset has been substantially improved during the marriage by the other spouse or by both spouses, or

2. it is the matrimonial home.

Substantial improvement

For the non-owner spouse of the asset to substantially improve the asset, he/she must either invest money in it or invest effort which has economic value in it. For the investment of money, the Family Justice Courts have cited a paradigm example to be renovation works performed on a residential or commercial property. An example of an investment of effort which can transform a business into a matrimonial asset is the development of a business by the non-owning spouse or by both spouses during the marriage by sustained efforts.

Let’s illustrate this with a hypothetical example.

Mr and Mrs Tan have been married for 10 years, and have recently decided to get a divorce. During their marriage, Mrs Tan received a gift from her mother, a Cartier luxury watch. Ordinarily, this watch would not form part of the matrimonial pool as it is a gift purely from her mother to Mrs Tan.

However, during their marriage, the watch had stopped working, and Mr Tan brought the watch for repairs and paid for its repairs. Mr Tan had substantially improved the watch during the marriage, and this watch would now form part of the matrimonial pool.

Additionally, Mrs Tan’s father had passed away before she got married, and had left her a residential property located in Orchard Road. The residential property was transferred to Mrs Tan and continues to be registered in her sole name. After getting married, Mr Tan moved in with Mrs Tan into the property, and the couple continued staying there with their children for the rest of their marriage. Despite the Orchard Road property being an asset Mrs Tan inherited from her father and being in her sole name, it would form part of the matrimonial pool as it is now the matrimonial home of the parties.

Moving on to assets acquired otherwise than from gift/inheritance, these assets can be split into 3 categories:

1. Quintessential matrimonial assets;

2. Transformed matrimonial assets; and

3. Pre-marriage assets.

Quintessential Matrimonial Assets

As a start, all quintessential matrimonial assets will form part of the matrimonial pool. Quintessential matrimonial assets refer to:

1. assets which either spouse derived from income earned during the marriage (note: this includes salary earned);

2. assets to which either spouse or both spouses obtained legal title during the marriage by using their own money;

3. any other asset of any nature acquired during the marriage by one party or both parties to the marriage; and

4. the matrimonial home, whenever and however acquired.

Put simply, the matrimonial home and all assets acquired by either spouse/both spouses during the marriage, other than by gift/inheritance, constitute quintessential matrimonial assets, and will form part of the matrimonial pool.

We now move on to consider assets acquired by either spouse before the marriage, which can be divided into transformed matrimonial assets or pre-marriage assets.

Transformed Matrimonial Assets

All transformed matrimonial assets (the whole asset) will form part of the matrimonial pool. Transformed matrimonial assets refer to assets which were acquired before the marriage by either spouse, but which:

1. have been substantially improved during the marriage by the other spouse or by both spouses; or

2. were ordinarily used or enjoyed by both parties or their children while residing together for purposes, such as shelter (e.g. a vacation home), transport (e.g. a car) or household use (e.g. antique furniture in the home).

Let us use the earlier hypothetical example to illustrate.

Before Mr Tan got married, he was already the owner of 2 cars: a BMW X6 Sports Utility Vehicle (“SUV”), and a Porsche 911 Turbo sports car.

After the marriage, the SUV was regularly used to fetch family members around for activities like school, work and family outings. Thus, this SUV would form part of the matrimonial pool as it is a transformed matrimonial asset. This is because even though the SUV had been acquired by Mr Tan before his marriage, it was regularly used by both Mr Tan and Mrs Tan and their children while residing together for transport purposes.

However, the Porsche was generally driven around by Mr Tan only for his own activities during the marriage. Mr Tan does not allow his wife or children to use his Porsche. Mr Tan sends the Porsche for servicing and grooming. Thus, this Porsche would not form part of the matrimonial pool as it was neither substantially improved by Mrs Tan during the marriage, nor was it regularly used by the family.

Pre-Marriage Assets

Lastly, we consider the category of pre-marriage assets. Pre-marriage assets refer to assets that either spouse acquired before the marriage, which were not improved substantially by the non-owning spouse after marriage, nor were used for family purposes.

All pre-marriage assets will not form part of the matrimonial pool, unless they were partially paid for during the marriage by the owning spouse with income that would have been a quintessential matrimonial asset had it been saved up, rather than spent on the pre-marriage asset. In such a case, the asset would form part of the matrimonial pool, usually in the proportion of the value “acquired” or “invested” during the marriage.

Before getting married to Mrs Tan, Mr Tan was already the owner of a small vacation property in Phuket, Thailand.

During the marriage, neither parties nor their children visited the vacation property. Mr Tan however paid yearly maintenance fees from the parties’ joint account to refurbish and to maintain the vacation property as he hopes to sell the property one day for profit. The money used by Mr Tan for maintaining the property came from the parties’ earned income in their joint account. As these maintenance fees would have otherwise been saved up in the joint account, it is likely that the vacation property, or at least part thereof, would be included in the matrimonial pool. While we hope that the various examples above have helped you to better understand whether your asset would go into the matrimonial pool, these examples are but for illustration purposes only and are not meant to be legal advice.

In determining what asset would fall within the matrimonial pool and available for division would depend on how the parties acquired the asset, and how they lived and spent during their marriage. How the parties have enjoyed or used their assets will be specific to individual facts and circumstances and may lead to different outcomes depending on the facts.

Ultimately, the outcome weighs heavily on the specific facts of each case, which differ greatly from person to person. Being aware of whether your asset goes into the matrimonial pool allows you to make better decisions and take the necessary precautions to ensure that certain assets which you wish to safeguard will not be ordered to be split with your spouse in the event of a divorce.

At Jacque Law LLC, we have many years of experience handling a wide range of matrimonial matters (including contested and uncontested divorces). If you would like to discuss any of the above further, please do get in touch with us.

1 Singapore Court of Appeal decision of USB v USA and another appeal [2020] SGCA 57

Beware of your narcissistic spouse – 7 tips to divorce a narcissist

The term narcissism is derived from the Greek myth about the self-absorbed Narcissus who was cursed to fall in love with his own reflection in the water. Eventually, Narcissus killed himself over his unrequited love for his own image.

Narcissism can be categorized into two main types — grandiose and vulnerable narcissism. Individuals with the former tend to be charming and outspoken and often take on leadership positions. Famous figures like Donald Trump and Kanye West have been suspected to be grandiose narcissists. Vulnerable narcissists, on the other hand, possess more subtle traits and are usually characterized to be outwardly introverted and frequently shy away from the spotlight.

Narcissism exists on a spectrum, ranging from a few traits to a full-blown personality disorder. Full-fledged narcissism is a pervasive pattern of grandiosity (in fantasy or behaviour), a need for admiration, and a lack of empathy, usually beginning by early adulthood, and is indicated by five (or more) of the following traits1:

1. Having a grandiose sense of self-importance (e.g, exaggerating achievements and talents, expecting to be recognized as superior without commensurate achievements).

2. Being preoccupied with fantasies of unlimited success, power, brilliance, beauty, or ideal love.

3. Believing that one is “special” and unique and can only be understood by, or should only associate with, other special or people or institutions with high-statuses.

4. Requiring excessive admiration.

5. Having a sense of entitlement (e.g. having unreasonable expectations of especially favourable treatment or automatic compliance with one’s expectations).

6. Being interpersonally exploitative (e.g., taking advantage of others to achieve one’s own ends).

7. Lacking empathy i.e. being unwilling to recognize or identify with the feelings and needs of others.

8. Often being envious of others or believing that others are envious of oneself.

9. Showing arrogant, haughty behaviours or attitudes.

If you have observed the aforementioned traits in your spouse, you may have valid suspicions that your spouse is a narcissist. Do inform your lawyer of this suspicion as this can have an impact on how your divorce will be handled.

Considering a narcissist’s insatiable desire for control and victory, one can expect a narcissistic spouse to refuse mediation or to settle on reasonable terms.

Narcissists crave attention, especially from their spouses, and such attention may not always be positive attention. Creating chaos in another person’s life is something that a narcissist may strive to do to receive negative attention from that person. For example, a narcissist may aim to exert psychological stress on his or her spouse by charming and persuading family and friends to turn on his or her spouse. As narcissists often possess a lack of empathy, their own children may not be spared from their antics – some may resort to manipulating their children in a manner adverse to their children’s interests to alienate their children from their spouses.

In this article, we share feasible tips on dealing with a narcissistic spouse during a divorce.

1) Stay calm

A narcissist has the propensity to distort the truth, so it is crucial that you keep your cool during interactions with your spouse. One of a narcissist’s favourite moves is creating chaos for others, so that they can revel in seeing others struggle and feel superior as a result. Your spouse may try to incite you to have emotional outbursts to get attention from you or, if such outbursts are recorded, to evidence emotional instability on your part during the divorce proceedings so that the Family Court Judge sees you as the crazy one and them as the reasonable one.

Therefore, try to remain calm in your dealings with your spouse and avoid reacting defensively, for example, displaying any emotional distress or angry outbursts.

2) Limit communications

Limiting communication with your spouse helps to prevent them from exploiting your emotions or making false accusations against you. Try to keep interactions minimal and in writing. Not only will this allow you more time to compose yourself mentally and think before responding, but it also enables everything to be recorded in writing so that your spouse cannot go back on their word or misreport conversations.

3) Prepare copies of important documents

Divorce proceedings with a narcissist can very much seem like going to war— one might expect a narcissistic spouse to resort to underhanded tricks in order to win, such as hiding or disposing of paperwork.

In order to remain one step ahead, it would be wise to compile as many documents that you can find, such as credit card statements, investment records, insurance policies, etc.

We have had experiences with narcissistic spouses who would go so far as to lie to the authorities and make false accusations against their spouses. In one case, a client’s spouse had made baseless allegations of violence against him. Thankfully, our client had maintained and kept extensive records and proper evidence of his dealings with his spouse during the divorce, and was able to defend himself against those allegations. It is therefore vital to keep or retrieve proper records of everything.

Records need not be confined to financial records and statements. For example, mobile phone communication, emails and photos can help your case if you wish to establish that there has been abusive behaviour by your spouse. Properly evidenced facts and figures will be more credible to a court than allegations without evidence.

4) Choose your battles wisely.

As narcissists crave praise and affection, being on the opposite side of a divorce from a narcissist will likely establish you as an ‘enemy’ from their perspective. This can trigger feelings of abandonment and rage in them, prompting them to take extreme measures to regain a sense of control over the situation.

What could have been an amicable divorce can quickly turn into a high-conflict one where your spouse may seek to take everything away from you.

The narcissist’s game, especially wealthy ones, is to outspend you and ruin you financially. They may take out unnecessary applications to put pressure on you or simply to frustrate you.

Prioritise what is most important to you and decide on things that you can give up on. Letting go of some less important things to you can satisfy your spouse’s thirst to ‘win’, while at the same time safeguarding what is more important to you.

It is crucial to pick your battles wisely, as narcissists may be willing to prolong divorce proceedings in order for the chance to win, in the process wasting both parties’ time, money and energy. Setting realistic goals and choosing to give up on secondary things may be more worthwhile as you can avoid an unnecessarily long and hostile divorce process that you and your family will otherwise have to endure.

5) Have a solid support system.

Abusive narcissists tend to isolate their victims. Divorce is itself an emotionally exhausting process, so it is important to confide in family members, friends or even therapists with whom you can share your side of the story with. In the midst of the turmoil, you may neglect your own well-being. Do surround yourself with people whom you trust to advise and take care of you.

You will need a strong support system to maintain your mental health throughout the divorce proceedings. Do not be embarrassed to seek help for fear that your feelings are not justified. This is especially so if you have suffered from emotional manipulation by your spouse, as you may be used to being blamed and invalidated.

6) Create a parenting plan if you have children with a narcissistic spouse.

Co-parenting with someone you are embroiled in a divorce with is particularly challenging, much less with a narcissist who may use your children as a pawn in the proceedings in order to win. Therefore, designing and following a parenting plan for the period during the divorce will reduce confusion and conflict for both parents and children. You can enlist a family lawyer’s help to draw up a legal custody and access agreement to specify the sharing of costs and visitation / access schedules during the school term and during holidays.

Making the proposal as detailed as possible minimises any grey areas and serves to hold your soon to be former spouse accountable for his or her responsibilities in order to give your children a sense of normalcy and clarity. Though this may cost more compared to a generic parenting plan, it is advisable as you can set clear boundaries with your spouse for your children’s best interests and to reduce the risks of further disputes in future.

Furthermore, it will also serve to lessen the amount of contact and friction between you and your soon to be former spouse, thereby creating a more pleasant environment for your children to grow up in.

7) Seek an experienced family lawyer.

Hire a divorce lawyer who understands how divorcing a narcissist differs from normal cases. Though it takes a psychologist to diagnose someone with Narcissistic Personality Disorder, lawyers who have experience in acting for clients with narcissistic spouses can recognise certain traits and may be able to flag to you that your spouse is a narcissist.

Divorce lawyers who are experienced in handling protracted and complex divorce cases involving a narcissist can anticipate what a narcissistic spouse may do or say and devise a more effective strategy for you.

One must remember that narcissists love conflict, they love a battle and they will do anything to win no matter the cost. So unless you have unlimited money, you need to find a lawyer that can balance the unreasonable demands with logic and the tools of law to stop the narcissistic divorce train from running you into financial ruin.

Your lawyer needs to understand when to push the button of law and when not to react. Remember the narcissist’s goal is to get you to react. Your lawyer needs to be your rock to give you much-needed emotional and legal support, and be able to outwit your narcissistic spouse’s tactics to protect you from being manipulated.

We have been involved in many matrimonial and divorce proceedings involving narcissistic spouses, and have worked with clinical psychologists that are experts on narcissism While these cases tend to be more protracted than other normal divorces, narcissistic spouses tend to behave in a similar pattern. If you believe you are married to a narcissistic spouse, and plan to divorce him/her, please feel free to contact us to assist you in the strategy and your divorce journey.

If you would like to discuss any of these further, please do get in touch with us.

Child custody during and after divorce – Dangers of parental alienation

If you are newly divorced, undergoing a divorce, or considering separating from your spouse, we understand that this is not an easy time for you. If you and your spouse/former spouse have a child or children together, the situation can be even tougher.

During a time when tension between parents is at its highest and conflict regarding parenting responsibilities and access to children arises, some may worry that the spouse/former spouse may resort to parental alienation in an effort to control and hinder the emotional relationship the children would otherwise forge with them.

Parental alienation is a situation where one parent uses strategies to manipulate his/her child to have unjustified feelings of animosity or fear towards the other parent, in order to distance a child from the other parent.

Parental alienation may occur consciously or unconsciously. In fact, research indicates that in 11 to 15% of divorce cases, parental alienation was found to be present. It is estimated that 1% of children globally are subjected to some form of parental alienation with an equal distribution between fathers and mothers being alienated and doing the alienation (Bernet, von Boch-Galhau, Baker, & Morrison, 2010; Fidler & Bala, 2010; Kruk, 2011).

If you are a parent navigating a divorce, it is important that you be able to recognize the types of parental alienation, and have a plan to address any problems that may arise.

There are 3 main types of alienators:

i) Naïve alienators

The naïve alienator wants the child to have a good relationship with the other parent, does facilitate the child’s access with the other parent, and does not have any ill intentions. However, while the parent means well, the parent may unconsciously make passing remarks criticizing the other parent.

For example, “tell your mother it would help if she was on time to pick you up”, or “tell your father that he has more money than I do, so get him to buy you your new sports shoes”.

While those are trivial comments, it can cause the child to be apprehensive as to how to treat the other parent. Thankfully, this problem is likely to be easily solved once it is pointed out to the naïve alienator, reminding him / her to be more mindful of his / her words and actions.

ii) Active alienators

An active alienator is similar to a naïve alienator in that they both believe that children should have a good relationship with both parents. Like naive alienators, they are able to differentiate between their needs and those of the children by supporting the children’s desire to have a relationship with the other parent.

However, unlike a naïve alienator, an active alienator tends to have strong feelings of bitterness or frustration towards the other parent.

As such, they struggle with not letting their own pain affect their behaviour during the co-parenting and divorce journey. Their problem has more to do with loss of self-control when they are upset with the other parent than with a sinister motivation. Hence, this may result in angry outbursts and complaints, or arguments with the other parent in front of the children.

For example:

“Why did you have to tell your father that your swimming classes are cancelled? The miser will now ask his attorney to deduct the swim coach fees from the child’s maintenance. I plan to use the money for a staycation with you. You remember he has done it before and deprived us of the spare cash for our Christmas party.”

While active alienators generally comply with the access and maintenance court orders, they can be very rigid and uncooperative with the other parent. This is usually a passive attempt to strike back at the other parent.

For example, in a court order that was previously agreed by the parties a few years ago, both parents agreed that the father could bring the child for an annual overseas trip for up to 7 days during the school holidays. However, due to the COVID-19 travel restrictions, the father wanted to bring the child for a staycation instead. The mother refused as a staycation does not constitute an “overseas trip”. As a result, this necessitated us having to take out a Court application in the Family Justice Courts on the father’s behalf to vary the initial court order to allow him to bring the child for staycations.

For the most part, older children have their own views about both parents based upon their personal experience rather than what they are told by others. To maintain harmony, the older child usually learns to keep their views to themselves. The younger and more trusting children tend to be in a dilemma as to which parent they should believe and more vulnerable to the active alienator’s manipulation.

Since active alienators do not usually have any malicious intent and have a genuine desire to act in the child’s best interest, they may act rationally after calming down. They may apologise to the child or the other parent. They are also open to accept professional help as well as attend mediation sessions to resolve any underlying issues with the other parent.

iii) Obsessed alienators

Unlike the 2 aforementioned alienators, an obsessed alienator speaks or acts with the purpose of causing estrangement.

Obsessed alienators typically present with narcissistic or borderline personality traits. When their relationship ends with the targeted parent, for whatever reason, the obsessed alienator experiences an abnormal grief reaction called narcissistic injury. They will intensely feel the loss and embarrassment of the loss. They will externalise the cause of their pain and will want the targeted parent to suffer for their pain.

The obsessed alienator has an unquenchable anger and bitterness towards the other parent, and these feelings do not subside but instead becomes more intense as he/she is being forced to continue a relationship with an ex because of the children. While they combine traits of naïve with active alienation, they lack any level of self-control or insight.

The alienating parent will want his child to be firmly on his/her side and turn his/her child against the other parent by giving biased perceptions of the targeted parent. For instance, if the other parent is not free to meet their child as scheduled, the alienator will tell their child that the other parent does not care or want to meet them.

For example, “Your mother is not free because she is busy dating. Just like how she abandoned me for another man during the marriage, she will no longer care for you once she starts a new family. I, however, will always be here for you.“

Obsessed alienators may also find ways to prevent their child from interacting with the other parent and plant seeds of doubt in the child’s mind about the alienated parent. For example, the parent might reconstruct past events to make the child believe nasty and untrue things about the other parent. The obsessed alienators may also manipulate the legal system in order to deprive the other parent from access to the child.

In one of our cases, the obsessed alienator mother lodged a false police report and filed a personal protection order against the child’s father. The child’s mother lied that the child’s father pointed a knife at the child when the child was sleeping and threatened to kill the child and the mother. The child’s mother also submitted pictures of cuts on the child’s arm and claimed that the cuts were inflicted by the child’s father.

Although these were all lies, the child’s father was deprived of his access to the child for many months as the child was so terrified of her father that she refused to spend time with him. It also took months of mediation and counselling before the obsessed alienator finally agreed to withdraw her personal protection order application against the child’s father as it was made without any basis.

Divorce inevitably creates stress and tension for everyone in the family. Children often face difficult adjustments in this transition period. When one parent attempts to sabotage their child’s relationship with the other parent, it is the child who suffers the most. Parental alienation prevents children from receiving the reassurance and support they need—from both parents—to successfully adapt and adjust to their new family dynamics.

Is parental alienation affecting your relationship with your children and your child custody arrangements?

We understand that alienation from your child can be devastating and we will work with you to strengthen and repair your relationship with your child. You do not need to be defenseless to the alienator’s tactics.

Please feel free to contact us at 6280 7388 or drop us a WhatsApp to explore how we can best help you.

Retrenchment – How does it affect child maintenance under the Women’s Charter?

In a divorce, the soon to be ex husband and wife may agree on the terms of the monthly payments to be made by one party to the other. If no agreement can be reached, they must await determination by the Family Justice Courts. Upon divorce, the terms of such payments will be recorded in a Family Court Order that is binding on the parties.

These payments are commonly referred to as maintenance. There are two types of maintenance – spousal maintenance (or alimony as it is more commonly known) and child maintenance.

While a court order on maintenance is binding on the parties, the terms of such an order can be changed provided both parties agree to the change. Otherwise, the party seeking for the change must convince the Family Justice Court that there has been a “material change in circumstances” in order for the Family Justice Court to order a change to the maintenance terms.

We have seen a rise in numbers of retrenchment and wage cuts, and a corresponding increase in our caseload for applications to vary and reduce maintenance payment obligations.

In this article, we aim to help you better understand the factors that will be taken into account when determining if a variation should be granted in the event of a party’s retrenchment. For an overview, see financial support after divorce.

For the purposes of this article, we will only be focusing on child maintenance. To determine if a variation of child maintenance ought to be granted, the Family Court judges will look at a variety of factors, which we will elaborate on below.

Overview

According to the Women’s Charter, the Court has the power to vary a child maintenance order if and when there has been a material change in circumstances.

At first blush, retrenchment of the paying party seems to be a material change in circumstances warranting a reduction in one’s maintenance obligations. After all, the paying party ceases to have a source of monthly income. However, a mere change in financial circumstances is generally insufficient. The change in financial circumstances must be adverse towards the party seeking for the variation. The Court will consider other factors to determine this, including the retrenched party’s financial position and if there has been a change in standard of living.

In addition, since the welfare of the child/children would be paramount, the judges in the Family Court will also consider the impact a variation order (if they were to grant it) will have on the child/children.

Retrenched Party’s Financial Position

The Family Justice Courts will look at the retrenched party’s financial position. Income from employment is but just one aspect of a party’s financial position. Other factors to consider would include the amount of savings the retrenched party has, his existing liabilities, and the size of the severance package given at retrenchment are also crucial. The Family Justice Courts will consider these different aspects before making a judgement on the retrenched party’s financial position.

Let’s illustrate this with a hypothetical example.

Ethan has been retrenched from his company and seeks to vary the child maintenance downwards. At time of retrenchment, Ethan only received two months’ salary as his severance package. Since his retrenchment, he has not been able to find a job and has been unemployed for more than six months. As Ethan has an existing mortgage and an elderly mother to care for, he is now gravely in debt. Two of his credit cards have been cancelled, and he is struggling to pay his income tax arrears. In contrast, Ethan’s ex-spouse is well-off and owns two properties and a car.

In such a situation, given Ethan’s impoverished state following his retrenchment, his loss of income will likely be sufficient to constitute an adverse change in financial circumstances. If, however, Ethan amassed huge amount of savings over the years and received a large sum of money in his severance package, the Family Justice Courts may not hold that there has been an adverse change in Ethan’s financial circumstances.

Retrenched Party’s Standard of Living

In addition, the Family Justice Courts will also consider the retrenched party’s standard of living. The applicant seeking the variation must prove that there has been a material change in his own standard of living.

Consider another hypothetical example:

Leonardo has been retrenched from his company. As a result, Leonardo has decided to cut back on his luxury expenses and has sold his Porsche sports car. He has however not moved out of his apartment in Orchard Road, and has not cut down on his food and entertainment expenses. Leonardo now relies on the sale of his Porsche as evidence for a material change in his standard of living to reduce his child maintenance obligations.

In such a case, it is unlikely that the sale of the sports car is itself sufficient to show that Leonardo’s standard of living has materially changed. This is because a sports car is a luxury that Leonardo could definitely live without. When a party is retrenched, it is almost expected that he or she would eliminate luxuries. Thus, such elimination is in itself inadequate to prove that the change in standard of living is indeed material.

To prove that the change in standard of living is material, based on our experience dealing with similar applications, it is necessary for Leonardo to show that he has reduced his personal expenses in a meaningful manner, such as tightening of the belt with regards to necessitates. For example, cutting down on expenses such as hobbies (selling his golf membership, forgoing his weekly karaoke night), and entertainment and dining out.

Impact the variation has on the children

Even if the above two factors lie in favor of finding a material change in the party’s circumstance, the Family Justice Courts may not necessarily grant the variation of child maintenance.

Family law fundamentally recognises that each biological parent has an independent and non-derogable duty to maintain the child. When deciding cases, protecting the children’s welfare will always be the paramount consideration of the Family Justice Courts. Thus, notwithstanding that the retrenched parent’s circumstances has been materially affected, the Family Justice Courts will not automatically grant a variation but will instead take into consideration whether it is reasonable for the welfare of the child that the maintenance be varied.

This begs the question of what is considered “reasonable for the welfare of the child”. To determine this, the Family Justice Courts will need to first consider what the children’s reasonable expenses are and look at the parents’ respective salaries and/or earning capacities as an indicator of the proportion that each party should bear.

In the event that a downward variation of child maintenance will result in inadequate funds to support the child’s reasonable expenses and that it is unfair to expect the other party to increase his or her contribution towards the child’s maintenance, it is unlikely that the variation will be granted.

Conclusion

A party who gets retrenched may be interested in seeking a variation of the monthly maintenance sum. In our view, while the judges are sympathetic to the plight of the retrenched party, they take a wholistic approach to determine if the variation should be allowed.

Ultimately, the Family Justice Court’s decision for any family law matter will always revolve around a balancing game of the interests of the three parties – the Father, Mother and Child – with the child’s interest being paramount.

If you or your former spouse’s ability to maintain the children has been affected by a recent retrenchment, you may have to reach an agreement with your former spouse on how the existing child maintenance order ought to be varied.

To ensure that you can create the right arrangements for you, or if you’re unsure how to approach the issue of child maintenance, it’s worthwhile seeking advice from experienced family law solicitors.

If no agreement can be reached, a contested child maintenance dispute may be inevitable, which will only serve to add stress, costs and increase the acrimony between the parents.

At Jacque Law LLC, we have worked on many divorce cases involving child maintenance disputes, and can guide you through the entire process, providing dedicated advice specific to your circumstances.

Debt Recovery

Being a litigation focused firm, we are experienced in handling debt recovery and have helped various corporations and companies in their corporate debt recovery. Our lawyers have considerable experience in all aspects of debt recovery and dispute resolution, including the following

  • Issuance of letters of demand
  • Enforcement of court and/or tribunal orders, including garnishee orders, examination of judgment debtor and writ of seizure and sale.
  • Negotiations with debtors
  • Investigation and searches into debtor’s history and assets
  • Bankruptcy and Winding up

Our experience extends to recovery of debts of varying quantum and our lawyers have experience litigating at all levels of the Singapore courts. For example, our lawyers have acted for a leading property developer in relation to the recovery of outstanding payments due from different individual purchasers of its properties, and construction companies in relation to recovery of outstanding payment for services rendered to their suppliers.

Our aim for any engagement is to help you recover the debt. This ideally means we recover early, and avoid going to court.

For illustration, we set out below the typical steps of escalation that occur in debt recovery cases.

1. Obtaining your instructions and review of documentation

  • We will speak to you to have a full understanding of your current situation so we can advise on the appropriate next steps.
  • We will carry out an earlier evaluation to assess any potential issues that may arise and guide you on the options available, timing and costs. For corporate clients, we can also offer you debt management advice on how to improve your terms and conditions and processes.

2. Debtor investigations

  • Perform due diligence on the debtor to ascertain the financial capability to pay back any debt.

3. Issuance of Letter of Demand

  • The letter of demand is used to provide notice of a party’s intention to enforce their rights, such as the recovery of debt (personal loans or when there has been a breach of a contract in a business relationship). It is also worth noting that if you anticipate that the debtor will breach an agreement or contract, you can also send them a letter of demand.
  • To be used (if necessary) in court to provide evidence of a parties attempt to recover the debt prior to bringing the matter to the appropriate court.

4. Communications between debtor and creditor

  • We await a response from the debtor after their receipt of the letter of demand. We will support in negotiation between parties where required.

5. Filing of Court Action

  • If the letter of demand proves unsuccessful we can then file a claim with the appropriate court. The amount and type of claim will depend on the route taken.

6. Enforcement of Court Order

  • Even after a successful court decision, it is possible that the debtor may still not pay up. We will advise on the appropriate next steps to enforce the collection of the debt.

As the process of debt recovery is unique to each situation, the above should not be construed as legal advice. Our lawyers will advise you on the appropriate steps as part of your consultation with us.