Informed Consent in Singapore: What Your Doctor Must Tell You Before Treatment

In Singapore, a doctor’s duty to advise is governed by section 37 of the Civil Law Act 1909, in force since 1 July 2022. A doctor must give the information a reasonable patient in your circumstances would need, plus information the doctor knows or ought to know matters to you personally, unless there is a reasonable justification for withholding it. The outcome depends on your specific facts, so please consult a qualified lawyer.

You agreed to a procedure. Afterwards, a complication occurred that nobody had mentioned. Was that negligence? The answer may turn on informed consent: what your doctor had to tell you before you decided. Singapore’s law on this changed significantly in 2017 and was written into statute in 2022.

How the Law on Informed Consent Developed in Singapore

For many years, the courts judged doctors’ advice by the Bolam test: a doctor was not negligent if a responsible body of medical opinion would have acted the same way, provided that opinion was logical (Bolitho). The focus was on what doctors considered acceptable.

In Hii Chii Kok v Ooi Peng Jin London Lucien [2017] SGCA 38, the Court of Appeal moved to a more patient-centred approach for medical advice, drawing on the UK decision in Montgomery. The question became what information would be relevant and material to the patient, not only what doctors usually disclose. The court kept the Bolam and Bolitho test for diagnosis and treatment.

Parliament then codified the standard for medical advice in section 37 of the Civil Law Act 1909, inserted by the Civil Law (Amendment) Act 2020 and in force from 1 July 2022.

What Section 37 Requires Your Doctor to Tell You

Under section 37, a doctor meets the standard of care for medical advice if a respectable body of medical opinion accepts their conduct as reasonable, and that opinion is logical. But that medical opinion can only be relied on if it requires the doctor to have given the patient:

  • information that a person in the patient’s circumstances would reasonably require to make an informed decision about the treatment or advice, and
  • information the doctor knows or ought reasonably to know is material to that particular patient, even if most patients would not need it.

Whether information is material to you personally depends on concerns you expressly raise with the doctor, or concerns that ought to be apparent from your medical records that the doctor can access and should review.

The Act gives examples. A patient who asks about paralysis after a flu vaccination should be told about a very rare nerve complication that doctors would not normally mention, because the patient raised the concern. Similarly, if a patient’s earlier records show repeated concerns about a particular side effect of knee surgery, a later surgeon at the same hospital ought to address it, even if the patient does not raise it again.

Under section 37(4), the fact that other respected doctors hold different views does not, by itself, stop a doctor from relying on the peer professional opinion.

When Can a Doctor Hold Back Information?

A doctor can withhold information only where there is reasonable justification. The Act’s illustrations make the line clear:

SituationReasonable justification?
Emergency life-saving surgery on an unconscious patient, with no one available to decide for themYes
A patient has already been advised by other specialists and clearly says they do not want the information againYes
The doctor believes the patient needs the procedure and fears that explaining the risks would put them offNo, not by itself

Is a Signed Consent Form Enough?

A signed consent form is evidence that a discussion took place, but it does not settle the question on its own. The law looks at what information was actually given and whether it met the section 37 standard. A form listing general risks may not cover a risk that was material to you because of a concern you raised.

From Missing Information to a Claim

Showing that you were not told something is only part of a claim. You would generally also need to show that, if you had been properly informed, you would have made a different decision, for example declining the procedure or choosing another option, and that you suffered loss as a result.

For the steps in bringing a claim, time limits and compensation, see filing a medical negligence claim in Singapore and how to identify and respond to medical negligence.

Practical Steps for Patients

  • Raise your specific concerns. Under section 37(3), concerns you expressly communicate become material to you. Write them down before the consultation.
  • Ask about alternatives, including the option of not having the treatment at all.
  • Keep notes of what you were told, by whom and when.
  • Request your medical records if you later have concerns about what happened.

If you believe you were not given information you needed before treatment, our medical negligence team can review your situation. See our medical negligence services.

Frequently Asked Questions

Does section 37 apply to dentists?

Yes. Section 37 applies to healthcare professionals who provide medical advice, and expressly includes registered medical practitioners, dentists and oral health therapists.

What if the patient is a child or lacks capacity?

Section 37 treats the person responsible for making the decision for the patient, such as a parent, as the patient for the purposes of the duty to advise.

Does informed consent apply to diagnosis mistakes?

No. Informed consent concerns the advice given before a decision. Claims about diagnosis or treatment are generally assessed under the Bolam and Bolitho test.

This article is for general information only and does not constitute legal advice. Please consult a qualified lawyer for advice on your specific situation.

Sources

Can You Contest a Will in Singapore? Grounds, Caveats and Family Provision Claims

In Singapore, a will can be challenged if it was not properly signed and witnessed under section 6 of the Wills Act 1838, or if the testator lacked mental capacity, did not know and approve its contents, or was unduly influenced. Separately, certain family members can claim maintenance from the estate under the Inheritance (Family Provision) Act 1966. The outcome depends on your specific facts, so please consult a qualified lawyer.

Finding out that a parent’s or spouse’s will leaves you less than you expected, or nothing at all, is painful. It also raises a practical question: can you do anything about it? You can contest a will in Singapore, but only on specific legal grounds. A will that seems unfair is not, by itself, invalid.

Who Can Contest a Will in Singapore?

A person with an interest in the estate can contest a will. That usually includes:

  • beneficiaries named in the will who would receive more under an earlier will
  • beneficiaries under an earlier will that the challenged will replaced
  • family members who would inherit under the intestacy rules if the will were set aside

So yes, a beneficiary can contest a will, for example where a later will reduced their share. What matters is whether the person would be better off if the challenged will were found invalid.

Grounds to Contest a Will

GroundWhat it means
Not properly executedUnder section 6 of the Wills Act 1838, a will must be in writing, signed at the end by the testator (or by someone in their presence and at their direction), and signed or acknowledged in the presence of two witnesses present at the same time, who must also sign.
Lack of testamentary capacityThe testator did not understand what a will is, the extent of their property, or who might have a claim on it, when the will was made.
Lack of knowledge and approvalThe testator did not know and approve the contents of the will, for example where it was prepared by someone who benefits from it.
Undue influenceThe testator was coerced into making the will, so that it reflects someone else’s wishes rather than their own.
Fraud or forgeryThe will, or the signature on it, is not genuine.
RevocationThe will was later revoked, for example by a later will.

For worked examples of disputes based on capacity, undue influence and family circumstances, see 6 common inheritance disputes in Singapore.

Unfairness is not a ground. A testator in Singapore is generally free to leave their estate as they wish, including unequally among their children. See should each child get the same? The exception is the Family Provision route below, which is about maintenance, not fairness.

Act Early: Entering a Caveat

Under section 33 of the Probate and Administration Act, any person having or claiming an interest may enter a caveat after the death and before a grant of probate or letters of administration is made. Once a caveat is in place, no grant can be made until the caveator has had the opportunity to contest the applicant’s right to it.

A caveat is a protective step, not a finding that the will is invalid. It should only be entered where there is a genuine basis for concern, because the matter may then need to be resolved in court and legal costs can follow.

If Probate Has Already Been Granted

A grant is not necessarily the end of the matter. Under section 32, a grant of probate or letters of administration may be revoked or amended for any sufficient cause, for example where a will is later shown to be invalid or a later will is found. The practical difficulty is that once assets have been distributed, recovering them becomes harder, so it is important to act as soon as you have concerns.

When the Will Is Valid: Claims Under the Inheritance (Family Provision) Act

Some family members can ask the court for maintenance from the estate even if the will is perfectly valid. Under section 3 of the Inheritance (Family Provision) Act 1966, where a person dies domiciled in Singapore, the following dependants can apply if the will (or the intestacy rules) does not make reasonable provision for their maintenance:

  • a wife or husband
  • a daughter who has not married, or who cannot maintain herself because of mental or physical disability
  • a son under 21
  • a son who cannot maintain himself because of mental or physical disability

Key points:

  • The claim is for maintenance, not an equal share. Provision is usually by periodic payments, which end on events such as remarriage or a son turning 21. Where the net estate is $50,000 or less, the court can order a lump sum.
  • There is a strict time limit. The application must generally be made within six months from the date the grant of probate or letters of administration is first taken out (section 4). The court can extend this only in limited situations, such as the discovery of a new will.
  • The court looks at the whole picture, including the dependant’s own means and conduct, and the deceased’s reasons for the way the will was written, where those can be ascertained.

How a Will Dispute Usually Proceeds

  1. Get advice early. Bring whatever you have: a copy of the will, any earlier will, and information about the testator’s health and circumstances when the will was signed.
  2. Gather evidence. Depending on the ground, this may include medical records, evidence from the witnesses to the will or the lawyer who prepared it, and messages or documents from the relevant period.
  3. Protect your position. Consider a caveat if probate has not yet been granted, and note the six-month limit if you may have a Family Provision claim.
  4. Try to resolve it. Negotiation or mediation can settle a will dispute without a trial, and is usually faster and less costly.
  5. Court proceedings. If there is no agreement, the court decides whether the will is valid, and deals with any Family Provision claim.

The court decides who bears the legal costs. A party who brings an unsuccessful challenge may be ordered to pay part of the other side’s costs, so have a lawyer assess the strength of your case before you start.

If you are considering a challenge, or you are an executor facing one, our team can advise on your position. See our contested probate and inheritance dispute services. Beneficiaries concerned about how an estate is being handled may also wish to read about the right to an account from the executor.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I contest a will just because it is unfair?

No. Unfairness alone is not a ground. You would need to show a legal defect, such as improper execution, lack of capacity, lack of knowledge and approval, undue influence or fraud. Certain dependants may, however, claim maintenance under the Inheritance (Family Provision) Act.

Can a beneficiary contest a will?

Yes, if the beneficiary would be better off if the will were set aside, for example because an earlier will gave them a larger share.

Is there a deadline to contest a will?

Family Provision claims must generally be made within six months of the first grant. For challenges to the validity of a will, it is best to act before probate is granted, for example by entering a caveat, because it becomes harder once the estate has been distributed.

Does contesting a will always mean going to court?

No. A dispute can be settled through negotiation or mediation. Court proceedings are needed where the parties cannot agree.

If you are Muslim, the Administration of Muslim Law Act 1966 (AMLA) and the Syariah Court apply. This article covers civil law only.

This article is for general information only and does not constitute legal advice. Please consult a qualified lawyer for advice on your specific situation.

Sources

Child Custody for Fathers in Singapore: Custody, Care and Control, and Access

In Singapore, fathers and mothers have equal standing in custody cases. Section 3 of the Guardianship of Infants Act 1934 states that neither parent has a superior right, and the court decides custody, care and control and access based on the child’s welfare. Joint custody is the usual starting point. The outcome depends on your specific facts, so please consult a qualified lawyer.

Many fathers going through a separation ask the same question first: will the court automatically side with the mother? The short answer is no. Singapore law gives both parents equal standing. What follows looks at custody, care and control and access from a father’s point of view, and at how to show the court the part you play in your child’s life.

Do Singapore Courts Favour Mothers in Child Custody Cases?

The law does not. Section 3 of the Guardianship of Infants Act requires the court to treat the child’s welfare as the first and paramount consideration, and states that the father shall not be deemed to have any right superior to the mother, nor the mother any claim superior to the father.

The Women’s Charter says the same in the divorce context. Under section 125, the child’s welfare is paramount, and subject to that, the court considers the wishes of both parents and the wishes of the child if the child is old enough to express an independent opinion.

What matters, then, is not whether you are the father or the mother, but what arrangement best serves your child. The court looks at the facts of each family, including who has been caring for the child day to day.

What Fathers Can Ask For: Custody, Care and Control, and Access

OrderWhat it meansWhat fathers typically seek
CustodyThe right to make major decisions about the child’s upbringingJoint custody, so both parents share decisions on schooling, religion and major medical treatment
Care and controlWhich parent the child lives with day to dayCare and control, or shared care and control where both homes can support it
AccessTime with the child for the parent without care and controlRegular weekday and weekend access, overnight stays, holidays and overseas travel

On custody, the Court of Appeal in CX v CY [2005] SGCA 37 held that joint custody should generally be ordered, with sole custody reserved for exceptional cases, such as where one parent abuses the child or the parents’ relationship makes co-operation impossible and this harms the child. For most fathers, joint custody is therefore the usual outcome rather than something to fight for.

Can a Father Get Care and Control?

Yes. Care and control is decided on the child’s welfare, and fathers are granted it where that is best for the child. Factors the court may consider include:

  • who has been the child’s main caregiver so far, and the importance of continuity for the child
  • the child’s age, health and educational needs
  • each parent’s home, working hours and support network, such as grandparents who help with care
  • the child’s relationship with each parent and with any siblings
  • the child’s own wishes, if the child is old enough to express an independent opinion
  • each parent’s willingness to support the child’s relationship with the other parent

In suitable cases, the court can also order shared care and control, where the child spends substantial time living with each parent. This usually needs parents who live reasonably close to each other and can communicate about the child.

Access Arrangements for Fathers

If the mother has care and control, the father will usually be granted access. Access can take many forms: weekday dinners, weekend or overnight stays, school-holiday periods, public holidays and festive occasions, and travel overseas with the child. In CX v CY, for example, the father was allowed to take the child out of Singapore once every six months for up to 14 days.

Supervised access is ordered in some cases, usually where there are concerns about the child’s safety or where a relationship needs to be rebuilt gradually.

If You Are Being Denied Access

For breaches on or after 2 January 2025, you can apply to the Family Courts to enforce a child access order. The court can order make-up access, compensation for reasonable expenses, counselling, mediation, parenting or therapeutic programmes, a compliance bond, or a fine of up to $20,000 or imprisonment of up to 12 months.

Two points to keep in mind:

  • Keep paying maintenance. Maintenance and access are separate obligations. Stopping maintenance because access is being denied can put you in breach of a maintenance order. See our page on child and spousal maintenance.
  • Keep a record. Note the dates, times and circumstances of each missed access, and keep your messages polite and child-focused.

If one parent is actively turning the child against the other, read our article on parental alienation. If the arrangement no longer works for other reasons, see how to change a child custody order.

Fathers Who Were Not Married to the Child’s Mother

The Women’s Charter provisions on custody apply in divorce, judicial separation and nullity proceedings. If you were not married to your child’s mother, you can apply for orders on custody, access and maintenance under section 5 of the Guardianship of Infants Act 1934, which allows either parent to apply. The same welfare principle applies. Because this is a different application, get legal advice on the right procedure.

How Fathers Can Prepare

  • Stay involved and document it. School meetings, medical appointments, bedtime routines and weekend activities all show your role in your child’s life.
  • Propose a realistic parenting plan. Show how your working hours, home and support network would actually work for your child.
  • Complete any required parenting programme. Parents with young children may need to attend the Mandatory Co-Parenting Programme before filing for divorce. See how the programme works.
  • Support the other parent’s relationship with the child. Courts look for parents who can co-parent. Criticising the other parent in front of the child, or in messages, rarely helps.

Our family lawyers act for fathers in custody, care and control and access matters. See our child custody page to find out how we can help.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can a father get sole custody in Singapore?

Sole custody is exceptional for either parent. Following CX v CY, it is generally reserved for cases such as abuse, or where the parents cannot co-operate at all and this harms the child.

Does the age of my child affect my chances of care and control?

The child’s age is one factor because it affects the child’s needs. It does not decide the case on its own; the court looks at the child’s overall welfare.

Will the court ask my child which parent they want to live with?

The court has regard to the child’s wishes where the child is old enough to express an independent opinion. How those views are obtained depends on the case and the child’s age.

If you are Muslim, the Administration of Muslim Law Act 1966 (AMLA) and the Syariah Court apply. This article covers civil law only.

This article is for general information only and does not constitute legal advice. Please consult a qualified lawyer for advice on your specific situation.

Sources

How to Change a Child Custody Order in Singapore

In Singapore, section 128 of the Women’s Charter 1961 allows the court to vary or rescind an order for custody, care and control or access if the order was based on a misrepresentation or mistake of fact, or if there has been a material change in circumstances. The child’s welfare remains the paramount consideration. The outcome depends on your specific facts, so please consult a qualified lawyer.

A custody order is made for a child at one point in time. Children grow, parents change jobs or move house, and an arrangement that worked when a child was four may not work at twelve. Singapore law lets either parent ask the court to change a child custody order when things have genuinely changed.

For how custody is decided in the first place, see our page on child custody in Singapore.

When Can You Change a Child Custody Order in Singapore?

Under section 128 of the Women’s Charter, the court may vary or rescind a custody, care and control or access order on the application of any interested person where:

  • the order was based on a misrepresentation or mistake of fact, or
  • there has been a material change in the circumstances.

The Family Justice Courts describe the test this way: you must show that the circumstances when the order was made are so different from the current circumstances that the order needs to be modified. A change that is minor or temporary is unlikely to be enough.

Orders made outside divorce proceedings, for example between parents who were never married, can be varied under section 5 of the Guardianship of Infants Act 1934, which allows either parent to apply to alter, vary or discharge an order.

Situations that may amount to a material change include:

  • a parent planning to move overseas, or a significant move within Singapore that affects schooling
  • a change in a parent’s work pattern that makes the current care arrangement unworkable
  • the child’s needs changing as they grow older, for example around a change of school
  • concerns about the child’s safety or wellbeing in one household
  • one parent repeatedly failing to follow the existing arrangement

Whatever the change, the question the court asks is the same as when the order was first made: what arrangement is in the child’s best interests now. Under section 125, the child’s welfare is the paramount consideration, and the court also considers the wishes of the parents and of the child, where the child is old enough to express an independent opinion.

Which Parts of the Order Can Be Changed?

OrderWhat it coversExample of a change
CustodyMajor decisions about the child’s upbringing, such as education, religion and serious medical treatmentMoving from joint custody to sole custody where joint decision-making has broken down and is harming the child
Care and controlWhich parent the child lives with day to dayTransferring care and control to the other parent, or moving to shared care and control
AccessThe other parent’s time with the childAdding overnight access as the child gets older, changing the schedule after a move, or adding supervision

You can ask to change one part and leave the rest unchanged.

How to Apply to Change a Custody Order

  1. Try to agree first. If both parents agree on the new arrangement, the change can be recorded as a court order by consent. The court still requires a supporting affidavit explaining why the change is in the child’s best interests.
  2. Use the right application. The court’s forms for varying custody, care and control and access include Form 55B, and the right form depends on which orders you want to change. If your divorce case began on or after 15 October 2024, you file a summons in the existing case. If it began before that date, the first variation is filed as an originating application, and later variations as summonses. See the court’s guide on varying a court order.
  3. Prepare your affidavit. The court expects it to set out the existing orders, any past variations, your proposed care plan for the child (including housing and schooling), and why the change is better for the child than the current arrangement. If you plan to move overseas with the child, you must also set out the care plan there and the proposed access for the parent who stays behind.
  4. Serve the other parent and attend the court process. The other parent can file a reply. The court may direct the parents to mediation or counselling to try to reach agreement before it decides.
  5. The court decides. If there is no agreement, the judge decides based on the affidavits and the child’s welfare.

Changing a Custody Order to Relocate Overseas

Relocation is a significant change because it usually reduces the other parent’s time with the child. A custody order may already include conditions about where the child lives or prohibit taking the child out of Singapore (s 126 Women’s Charter). Moving without the court’s permission or the other parent’s agreement can breach the order.

A relocation application should include a concrete plan: where the child will live and study, who will care for them, and how the child will keep a meaningful relationship with the other parent, for example through school-holiday visits and regular video calls.

What If the Other Parent Is Not Following the Current Order?

If the problem is that the existing order is being breached rather than that it no longer suits the child, enforcement may be the better route. For access breaches on or after 2 January 2025, you can apply to enforce a child access order. The court can order make-up access, compensation for reasonable expenses caused by the breach, counselling, mediation, parenting programmes, a compliance bond, or a fine of up to $20,000 or imprisonment of up to 12 months.

Repeated breaches can also be relevant evidence in a later variation application.

Practical Points Before You Apply

  • Keep the focus on your child. The application should explain what your child needs now, not revisit the conflict between the parents.
  • Keep records. Dates of missed access, school reports and messages between parents are more persuasive than general statements.
  • Do not change the arrangement on your own. Withholding access or keeping the child beyond agreed times while waiting for a hearing can count against you.
  • Think about timing. Where possible, avoid proposing changes in the middle of a school year or examinations.

Our family lawyers can advise on whether your situation is likely to justify a variation and help you prepare the application. See our child custody and divorce pages, or read more about co-parenting during and after divorce.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can we change the arrangement informally without going to court?

Parents can agree to vary the day-to-day arrangements between themselves, but an informal agreement cannot be enforced as a court order. If you want the change to be binding, apply to the court, even if you both agree.

Will the court listen to what my child wants?

Under section 125 of the Women’s Charter, the court has regard to the child’s wishes where the child is of an age to express an independent opinion. The child’s views are one factor; the overall test is the child’s welfare.

How often can a custody order be changed?

There is no fixed limit, but each application must show a material change in circumstances since the last order. An application that repeats arguments already decided, without a real change, is unlikely to succeed.

Do I need a lawyer to apply?

No, you can file the application yourself. A lawyer is worth considering where the change is contested, involves relocation, or raises safety concerns.

If you are Muslim, the Administration of Muslim Law Act 1966 (AMLA) and the Syariah Court apply. This article covers civil law only.

This article is for general information only and does not constitute legal advice. Please consult a qualified lawyer for advice on your specific situation.

Sources

Phantom Employment in Singapore: What Employers Risk If It Is Discovered

Phantom employment is more than an irregularity in a company’s CPF records. Where CPF contributions are made for individuals who do not genuinely work for the company, the arrangement may be used to inflate the company’s local workforce and, in turn, its foreign worker quota.

For employers, the consequences can extend well beyond the CPF contributions themselves. Depending on how the arrangement was used, the company and those responsible may face financial penalties, debarment from hiring foreign workers, criminal prosecution, tax exposure and personal liability.

Financial Penalties and Loss of Foreign Worker Quota

The Ministry of Manpower (“MOM”) has stated that employers who make work pass applications using CPF contributions made to existing phantom workers may face a financial penalty of up to S$20,000 for each work pass application made using the inflated quota. The employer may also be debarred from hiring foreign workers.

This means the criminal and/or financial exposure can increase with the number of work pass applications affected. An employer that has relied on an inflated local workforce over a period of time may therefore face severe financial consequences in respect of multiple applications, rather than a single penalty for the underlying arrangement.

Criminal Liability for False Work Pass Applications

Where the false employment records are used to support a work pass application, there are criminal procedures involved too.

Under section 22(1)(d) of the Employment of Foreign Manpower Act 1990 (“EFMA“), a person who makes a statement or furnishes information in connection with a work pass application which he or she knows, or ought reasonably to know, is false in a material particular, or misleading by reason of the omission of a material particular, commits an offence. The offence carries a maximum punishment of a fine of S$20,000, imprisonment for up to two years, or both.

The courts have emphasised the severity of such offences. In Chiew Kok Chai v Public Prosecutor [2019] SGHC 169 at [62], the High Court of Singapore held that imprisonment should generally be the norm for offences under section 22(1)(d), reflecting the need for deterrence where false declarations are deliberately made to obtain foreign workers. The Court subsequently reaffirmed this approach in Ferrer Luwi Inez Ramos v Public Prosecutor [2024] SGHC 245 at [84], while recognising that the appropriate sentence depends on the circumstances of each case. In determining the appropriate sentence, the court may consider factors including the materiality and sophistication of the false declaration, the offender’s role, the number of persons or applications involved, any financial gain and the offender’s motive, together with relevant mitigating circumstances.

Debarment and Business Disruption

For businesses that depend on foreign manpower, debarment may have consequences that extend beyond the financial penalty.

Where phantom employment has been used to inflate a company’s foreign worker quota, MOM may debar the employer from hiring foreign workers. Restrictions affecting work pass applications can also affect the company’s ability to maintain its existing workforce and disrupt current operations.

The practical impact can therefore be significant, particularly for labour-intensive businesses that rely on foreign workers to meet operational, contractual or project requirements. Employers should not treat debarment as a secondary consequence of a CPF irregularity: it may directly affect business continuity.

Tax and Government Scheme Exposure

Phantom employment may also create exposure outside the foreign manpower framework.

Where fictitious salary expenses or CPF contributions have been recorded for individuals who did not genuinely work for the company, the arrangement may also have income tax consequences. CPF Board has identified tax evasion as one reason phantom workers may be used, including arrangements involving fictitious salary expenses to reduce taxable income.

Similarly, false employment records may become relevant where the company has applied for government grants, payouts or other schemes based on its local workforce or employment figures. Depending on the circumstances, benefits obtained on the basis of false information may be recovered and further liability may arise.

The same records can therefore be examined by different authorities for different purposes. Resolving the CPF issue does not necessarily resolve the company’s wider exposure.

Personal Liability for Directors and Officers

One cannot hide behind the shield of the company. Under section 20 of the EFMA, where an offence by a company is committed with the consent or connivance of, or is attributable to the neglect of, a director, manager, secretary or other officer, that individual may also be made liable.

A director or officer therefore cannot necessarily avoid responsibility by pointing to a payroll employee or external service provider and disclaim liability. An investigation may examine who approved the arrangement, who knew how the local workforce figures were being used, and who authorised or signed the relevant work pass applications.

What Should Employers Do?

Employers who discover discrepancies between their CPF records, declared local workforce, and actual employment arrangements should address them promptly. This is particularly important where individuals may have been recorded as employees despite performing no work, previous work pass applications may have relied on those records, or tax filings and government scheme applications may have used the same information.

In situations where MOM or CPF Board is investigating the matter, employers should seek legal advice and cooperate with the authorities. A proper internal assessment should also be done as soon as possible, which would include the chronology of events, the relevant CPF and employment records, affected work pass applications, and any tax or government scheme claims that may have relied on the same information.

A lawyer advising a business client across a desk, with scales of justice and case documents

Whether you are an employer concerned about a possible phantom employment arrangement, a director or officer facing questions about the company’s workforce records, or a company responding to an MOM investigation, understanding the potential exposure early is relevant before determining the appropriate next steps. If your company is facing a suspected phantom employment issue, regulatory enquiry or investigation, please feel free to reach out to our firm for assistance.

The information provided in this article is for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. It should not be relied upon as a substitute for legal advice in relation to any particular circumstances. Specific legal advice should be sought where necessary.

Sources

A Job You Never Had: Who Is Responsible in a Phantom Employment Scheme?

Discovering CPF contributions from a company that you have never worked for can be concerning. You may never have applied for a position with the company, performed any work for it or even recognised its name, yet its contributions appear in your CPF account as though an employment relationship existed.

In such a situation, the existence of a false employment record is only the starting point. A phantom employment arrangement may involve the employer that created the record, directors or managers who authorised it, intermediaries who facilitated the arrangement and the individual whose particulars were used. Their respective legal positions may differ significantly depending on what each person did and knew.

Becoming Involved in a Phantom Employment Arrangement

An employer or intermediary may approach an individual and offer CPF contributions, cash or another benefit in exchange for the use of his or her personal particulars. CPF Board has warned members of the public against giving personal information to persons offering CPF contributions as a reward.

One person pointing to where another should sign a document, with no faces visible

Other cases may be less straightforward. A person may voluntarily provide personal information for one purpose without understanding that it will subsequently be used to create a false employment record. A person may also know that CPF contributions are being made but not understand the purpose for which the supposed employment is being recorded.

Personal particulars may also be obtained without the individual’s knowledge or involvement. CPF Board has noted that seniors may be particularly vulnerable to such arrangements. Not every person described as a “phantom worker” is therefore in the same position; knowledge, consent and conduct are important when assessing responsibility.

Close-up of an elderly person's hands, a group CPF Board has flagged as vulnerable to phantom employment schemes

Unfamiliar CPF Contributions and Individual Responsibility

A CPF record establishes that a contribution was made in the person’s name, but it does not by itself establish what that person knew or intended. The record may not show how the employer obtained the person’s particulars, what explanation was given or whether the individual understood that he or she was being represented as an employee.

A person whose particulars were used without permission is in a very different position from someone who knowingly agreed to be represented as an employee despite performing no work.

The existence of the CPF contribution may therefore prompt an investigation, but it does not by itself determine criminal responsibility.

Individual Liability and Knowing Participation

The legal risk is greater where an individual knowingly assists in the creation or operation of the false employment arrangement.

Under section 23(1) of the Employment of Foreign Manpower Act 1990 (“EFMA”), a person who abets an offence under the Act is liable to the punishment provided for the underlying offence. MOM has specifically warned that individuals who collude with companies by providing their particulars for fraudulent CPF contributions to inflate foreign worker quotas may be prosecuted for abetment of false declaration. Such offences may attract a fine of up to S$20,000, imprisonment for up to two years, or both.

An offer of “free CPF” should therefore not be regarded as harmless. Even where no work is required, the individual’s particulars may be used to create an apparent employment relationship that is later relied upon for work pass or foreign worker quota purposes. However, receiving CPF contributions does not necessarily prove that the individual understood the wider scheme.

Providing Personal Particulars Without Full Knowledge

CPF Board has warned that a person who provides CPF or Singpass details without knowing how the information will eventually be used may still be investigated. However, an investigation does not mean that an offence has necessarily been established.

Relevant questions may include why the information was provided, what the individual was told, whether any payment or benefit was offered and what the individual understood about the supposed employment. Messages, emails and other communications may therefore become important evidence of why the particulars were requested and what explanation was given.

Responsibility of Employers and Company Officers

Responsibility may extend beyond the individual whose name appears as the employee. A company acts through its directors, managers and other officers. An investigation may therefore consider who authorised the false employment records, who approved the CPF contributions, who prepared or approved work pass applications and who knew what the arrangement was intended to achieve.

Under section 20 of the EFMA, an officer of a company may in certain circumstances be proceeded against where an offence by the company was committed with that person’s consent or connivance, or was attributable to neglect on his or her part.

Accordingly, directors and managers should not assume that responsibility necessarily rests only with the employee responsible for payroll or an external service provider. The relevant inquiry may include what the officer knew, authorised or failed to supervise.

Role of Employment Agents and Intermediaries

Not every phantom employment arrangement is organised directly between an employer and the person whose particulars are used.

Intermediaries may be involved in recruiting individuals, obtaining personal particulars, connecting them with employers, arranging documents or coordinating payments. Depending on the conduct involved, responsibility may therefore extend beyond the employer and the phantom worker.

In July 2026, MOM announced the arrest of 14 individuals in an investigation into suspected employment-related offences. Those arrested included four company directors, nine foreign workers and a key appointment holder from an employment agency. MOM was also investigating suspected fraudulent CPF contributions made to 139 locals who were not employed by the companies concerned.

Evidence and Investigation

MOM may investigate the surrounding circumstances to determine whether genuine employment existed and who was involved in creating or facilitating the arrangement. Relevant evidence may include employment documents, salary and CPF records, work pass applications, communications between the parties, payment arrangements and statements provided during investigations.

The practical questions may include whether the individual ever performed work for the company, who first approached him or her, whether any payment or benefit was offered, what explanation was given for the CPF contributions, whether false employment documents were created and whether the individual introduced or recruited other persons into the arrangement.

These facts may help distinguish between an organiser of the scheme, an intermediary who actively facilitated it, a person who knowingly participated and a person whose particulars were used without his or her consent.

False Work Pass Declarations and Potential Penalties

Singapore courts have recognised the importance of protecting the integrity of the work pass system.

In Chiew Kok Chai v Public Prosecutor at [62], the High Court held that imprisonment should generally be the norm for false declaration offences under section 22(1)(d) of the EFMA involving work pass applications, reflecting the need for deterrence.

This does not mean that every person connected to a phantom employment arrangement will necessarily be prosecuted or receive a custodial sentence. Liability and sentencing depend on the offence, the person’s role and the evidence. The case nevertheless shows why false employment records may have consequences extending beyond the CPF contribution itself.

Steps to Take Upon Discovering Unfamiliar CPF Contributions

CPF members should review their transaction histories and pay attention to contributions from employers that they do not recognise.

Where there may be an innocent explanation, such as contributions continuing after a genuine employment relationship has ended, CPF Board recommends seeking clarification from the employer. If you are certain that you have never worked for the company concerned, CPF Board provides a channel for reporting invalid CPF contributions. Suspected use of locals as phantom workers may also be reported to MOM through its “Report an infringement” eService.

It is also advisable to preserve relevant records, including CPF statements, employment documents, messages, emails and any communications concerning the supposed employment. Where personal particulars were previously provided to another person, records of what was said and why the information was requested may become important if questions later arise about the individual’s knowledge or involvement.

A payroll binder and stationery on a desk, representing employment records worth preserving

Individuals should also avoid giving out Singpass credentials, CPF information or other personal particulars simply because they are offered CPF contributions or another benefit in return. What may appear to be a minor arrangement can result in the individual becoming involved in a wider employment investigation.

Determining Responsibility in Phantom Employment Arrangements

A phantom job may exist only on paper, but liability cannot be determined from the paper record alone. The law distinguishes between the person who creates the false employment, those who facilitate it, those who knowingly participate and those whose particulars may have been misused.

Accordingly, an unfamiliar CPF contribution should not automatically be treated as proof that the recipient has committed an offence. The circumstances surrounding the supposed employment, and in particular what each person knew and did, remain important.

Whether you are an individual who has discovered CPF contributions from an unfamiliar company, someone who has been approached to participate in such an arrangement, or an employer concerned about a possible investigation, understanding your legal position early can help you take the appropriate next steps. If you require advice concerning suspected phantom employment, an MOM investigation, false employment records or related offences under the Employment of Foreign Manpower Act, please feel free to reach out to our firm for assistance.

The information provided in this article is for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. It should not be relied upon as a substitute for legal advice in relation to any particular circumstances. You should seek specific legal advice where necessary.

Sources

Phantom Workers in Singapore: Why Would a Business Pay CPF to Someone Who Does No Work?

At first glance, there appears to be little commercial reason for a business to make CPF contributions for a person who performs no work for it. Yet this is precisely what may occur in a phantom employment arrangement.

The explanation lies not in the worker’s labour, but in what that worker may represent for regulatory purposes. In Singapore, the number of qualifying local employees a company has can affect the number of foreign workers it is permitted to employ. For an errant employer seeking to increase its foreign manpower capacity, an additional local employee recorded on paper may therefore carry a commercial benefit even where no genuine employment exists.

What is a phantom worker?

A phantom worker is a person who is declared as an employee of a company and receives CPF contributions even though he or she does not actually perform work for that employer. CPF Board describes phantom workers as persons who are declared as employees on paper and receive CPF contributions despite performing no work for the company.

This is different from a genuine employment relationship. Ordinarily, an employee performs work for a business, receives salary in return and, where required, has CPF contributions made by the employer. In a phantom employment arrangement, the records may still show CPF contributions or other signs of employment, but the underlying labour relationship is absent.

The existence of CPF contributions therefore does not, by itself, establish that genuine employment exists.

Mechanism of a phantom worker arrangement

The arrangement may begin when an employer or intermediary obtains the personal particulars of a Singapore citizen or permanent resident. The company then represents that person as an employee and makes CPF contributions in his or her name despite no genuine work being performed.

This matters because the Ministry of Manpower (“MOM”) uses information from employers’ CPF accounts when determining the number of local employees for foreign worker quota purposes. The Local Qualifying Salary, or LQS, is also relevant in determining how local employees count towards a company’s Work Permit and S Pass quota entitlement.

As at August 2026, a Singapore citizen or permanent resident employed under a contract of service and earning at least S$1,800 per month may count as one local employee for quota purposes. A person earning at least S$900 but less than S$1,800 may count as half a local employee, subject to the applicable requirements.

An errant employer may therefore seek to create the appearance that it employs more qualifying locals than it actually does. The inflated local headcount can then be used to support the hiring of additional foreign workers.

MOM does not simply accept every CPF record as proof of genuine employment. It has stated that it uses data analytics, inspections and investigations to detect companies that inflate their foreign worker quotas through phantom workers. Nevertheless, phantom employment seeks to take advantage of the fact that CPF and employment records are an important part of the system used to administer foreign manpower quotas.

A payroll file tab sitting on a ledger of salary figures

Rationale behind usage of phantom workers

The principal commercial incentive is access to foreign manpower.

Businesses cannot hire an unlimited number of foreign workers. The number they may employ depends on the quota applicable to their sector and the size of their qualifying local workforce. Once an employer reaches its quota, increasing its foreign manpower capacity will generally require it to employ more qualifying local workers.

Genuine local employment involves more than CPF contributions alone. It involves salaries, recruitment, training, supervision and the provision of actual work. A phantom arrangement attempts to obtain the regulatory benefit associated with an additional local employee without creating a genuine local job.

For an errant employer, the CPF contribution made for a phantom worker may therefore be treated as a cost of obtaining additional quota capacity rather than as payment for labour.

Foreign worker quota inflation is not the only possible motive. CPF Board has also warned that false employment records may be used to support fictitious business expenses or to obtain benefits under government schemes intended for businesses that genuinely employ or train local workers.

Relationship between local and foreign manpower

Singapore’s foreign manpower framework seeks to balance employers’ manpower needs with the need to maintain a strong local workforce.

The Dependency Ratio Ceiling, or DRC, limits the proportion of foreign workers that businesses in different sectors may employ. Current limits include 83.3% in construction and process, 75% in the marine shipyard sector, 60% in manufacturing and 35% in services.

The Local Qualifying Salary supports the same objective. It helps ensure that a local employee does not count fully towards foreign worker quota merely because his or her name appears on the payroll for a nominal amount. MOM has explained that the LQS is intended to ensure that local workers are employed and paid meaningfully while maintaining effective foreign workforce controls.

High-rise building under construction, one of the sectors subject to Singapore's Dependency Ratio Ceiling

Phantom employment undermines this framework because it creates the appearance of local employment without the genuine job that the system is intended to recognise.

Significance of phantom work arrangements

The consequences extend beyond an incorrect CPF contribution or an improperly obtained work pass.

If an employer artificially increases its local headcount, it may obtain foreign worker quota that it would not otherwise be entitled to. This weakens Singapore’s manpower controls and undermines the policy objective of maintaining a meaningful local workforce.

There is also a fairness issue between businesses. A compliant employer that genuinely hires local workers bears the full costs of salaries, CPF contributions, recruitment, training and supervision. A business using phantom workers attempts to obtain the same regulatory recognition without bearing those genuine employment costs, potentially placing compliant employers at a competitive disadvantage.

The issue remains current. In March 2026, MOM stated that enforcement action had been taken against around 100 employers in 2024 and 2025 for inflating foreign worker quotas through fraudulent CPF contributions. In July 2026, MOM also announced an investigation involving suspected fraudulent CPF contributions made to 139 locals who were not employed by the companies concerned.

Legal consequences for employers

MOM has stated that employers which inflate their foreign worker quotas may face a financial penalty of up to S$20,000 for every work pass application made using the inflated quota. They may also be debarred from hiring foreign workers.

False declarations made in connection with work pass applications may also amount to offences under the Employment of Foreign Manpower Act 1990. Depending on the conduct involved, this may lead to criminal prosecution.

The issue is therefore more than inaccurate paperwork. An investigation may consider why the false employment record was created, who authorised the CPF contributions, whether inaccurate information was used in work pass applications and which individuals were involved in the arrangement.

Magnifying glass resting on legal documents, representing an investigation into employment records

Employer Obligations and Best Practices

Employers should ensure that every person counted as part of the company’s local workforce corresponds to a genuine employment relationship. CPF contributions, salary records, employment contracts and work pass applications should accurately reflect the actual working arrangement.

Where discrepancies are identified, they should be reviewed promptly. The employer should consider how the discrepancy arose, whether any incorrect declarations have been made and whether corrective action is required.

Directors and managers should also be aware that responsibility may not end with the company itself. Under the EFMA, company officers may in certain circumstances be liable where an offence by the company was committed with their consent or connivance, or was attributable to neglect on their part.

Liability of Individuals in Phantom Employment Schemes

The fact that a person’s name appears in a phantom employment arrangement does not necessarily mean that he or she knowingly participated in it. The circumstances may differ depending on how the person’s particulars were obtained, what the person understood about the arrangement and whether there was any deliberate involvement.

We consider the position of individuals, as well as the potential responsibility of employers, company officers and intermediaries, in our next article, “A Job You Never Had: Who Is Responsible in a Phantom Employment Scheme?”

For employers, phantom employment is ultimately a foreign manpower and compliance issue, not merely an irregularity in CPF records. Businesses should ensure that their declared local workforce reflects genuine employment and address any discrepancies promptly.

If you require advice concerning suspected phantom employment, foreign worker quota issues, CPF records or a possible MOM investigation, please feel free to reach out to our firm for assistance.

The information provided in this article is for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. It should not be relied upon as a substitute for legal advice in relation to any particular circumstances. You should seek specific legal advice where necessary.

Sources

Your Rights During Maternity or Paternity Leave Disputes

Parenthood and Workplace Rights in Singapore

Navigating work while starting or expanding a family as a couple is a challenge. In Singapore, while both mothers and fathers alike are entitled to maternity and paternity leave to support their transition into parenthood, the process is not always conflict-free. Disputes may arise when employers deny, delay, or interfere with legally protected leave, or retaliate against employees who assert their rights.

Maternity Leave Rights: What the Law Guarantees

In Singapore, maternity leave protection and benefits are provided for under the Employment Act and the Child Development Co-Savings Act. 

Eligible female employees are entitled to either 16 weeks of government-paid maternity leave or 12 weeks under the Employment Act, depending on the child’s citizenship and other criteria.

To qualify for the full 16 weeks:(a) the child must be a Singapore citizen, and (b) the mother must have worked for the employer for at least three continuous months before the birth of the child.

If the child is a Singapore citizen but the second requirement is not satisfied, then the mother is only entitled to 12 weeks of unpaid maternity leave, if she is covered under the Employment Act.

If the child is not a Singapore citizen but the second requirement is satisfied, then the mother is entitled to 12 weeks of maternity leave, of which 8 weeks will be paid. The last 4 weeks would be unpaid maternity leave, subject to the specific terms of the mother’s employment  contract. 

Paternity Leave and Shared Parental Leave (SPL)

Fathers  enjoy parental leave rights too. Eligible working fathers are entitled to four weeks of government-paid paternity leave if: (a) the child is a Singapore citizen, (b) the father is lawfully married to the child’s mother between conception and birth, or within 12 months from your child’s date of birth and (c) the father has served his employer for a continuous period of at least 3 months before the birth of the child. 

If the child’s date of birth or estimated delivery date is between 1 April 2025 to 31 March 2026, both dates inclusive, the parents are entitled to 6 weeks of SPL to be shared between them. From 1 April 2026 onwards, working parents can enjoy up to 10 weeks of SPL, to be shared between parents and taken within 12 months from the child’s date of birth (inclusive of date of birth). 

Despite these protections, paternity leave often remains underutilized due to cultural stigma or lack of employer support. In some cases, employers deny leave requests or subtly discourage fathers from taking time off. However, such actions can breach the law and may open the employer to claims of discrimination or employment rights violations in Singapore.

Disputes Arising from Maternity and Paternity leave 

Common types of disputes surrounding maternity or paternity leave involve denial of entitlement, unpaid benefits, wrongful termination, or retaliation. 

The law mandates that employers cannot terminate a pregnant employee without cause, and certainly not because of her pregnancy or maternity leave. It is also an offence for an employer to dismiss an employee while he is on Government-Paid paternity leave. 

In some other instances, some employers may argue that employees on probation or contract are not entitled to parental leave, when in fact the law provides coverage based on minimum service period, not employment status. 

Some disputes may involve attempts to reduce compensation during leave. Cases like this are more clear cut and the position in law is clear – it is impermissible. 

What is more difficult to prove from an employee’s point of view, is retaliation after returning from maternity or paternity leave. This can manifest as exclusion from key projects, unfavorable performance evaluations, reduced bonuses, or being overlooked for promotions. In more severe cases, employees are dismissed shortly after returning to work, or reassigned to less favorable roles after returning to work.  

Employers must justify any performance or disciplinary decisions made post-leave. If an employee believes they were targeted because of their parental status or time away from work, they may have grounds to pursue a claim for wrongful dismissal.

Employees facing such challenges should document all communication related to their leave application and consult a lawyer to discuss his or her options. Ensuring that both parents take full advantage of their entitlements under the law strengthens the case for workplace equality and family support.

To address these problems, employees should first attempt to resolve the issue through direct communication with HR or management. Keeping written records of discussions, policies, and official leave requests to documenting the timeline of events, can serve as critical evidence and build a case if the matter escalates. A legal professional can assist with this, and it is recommended to seek legal advice promptly. If internal resolution fails, the next step is to file a formal complaint with MOM or a claim with the Employment Claims Tribunal.

Expecting a child is an exciting time, and workplace conflicts and doubts over your entitlements as an employee should not cloud the experience. Expecting parents who are employees would benefit from learning about their rights under the Employment Act and other relevant laws, and take the opportunity to understand their company’s HR policies and seek clarifications, if necessary.  

Legal Remedies and Avenues for Redress

When a dispute cannot be resolved internally, several legal channels are available. For wrongful dismissal or disputes over unpaid leave benefits, employees may lodge a claim through the Employment Claims Tribunals. If the dispute involves discrimination, including actions taken during pregnancy or due to parental status, it may be referred to the Tripartite Alliance for Fair and Progressive Employment Practices (TAFEP).

In more complex cases involving contract breaches or large financial loss, civil litigation may be pursued. However, this route is generally more costly and time-consuming, and employees are encouraged to explore mediation and advisory services before escalating.

Employer Obligations and Best Practices

Employers have legal obligations to process leave applications fairly, and avoid discriminatory practices. HR policies should be transparent, accessible, and aligned with current legislation.

Indeed, to minimize the risk of disputes, employers are encouraged to conduct regular training for management on Singapore employment law, especially regarding family-related leave. A fair and supportive workplace culture benefits not only employees but also fosters long-term loyalty, productivity, and brand reputation.

Employers should also maintain accurate records of leave requests, approvals, and communications. These documents may be essential in defending against false claims or clarifying misunderstandings during a dispute.

Whether you are an employee or an employer, understanding your legal position and being aware of your rights helps you take the next steps clearly, confidently and with peace of mind. Please feel free to reach out to our firm if you require assistance in this regard.

Non-Compete Clauses in Singapore

The Singapore High Court in a recent December 20251 judgement held that although modern commerce involves professionals moving frequently between companies, the principles of loyalty, integrity and fair dealing remain at the core of any functioning business environment, and the freedom of choice for clients to engage with whom they please, does not confer a parallel freedom on employees to quietly orchestrate transitions behind the scenes, nor does it diminish the importance of honouring reasonable restraint of trade provisions designed to ensure a level playing field. Reasonable restraint of trade clauses serve a vital purpose, which is to prevent individuals from unfairly exploiting the trust, goodwill and proprietary knowledge acquired in one role for the immediate benefit of another employer. 

Understanding the Nature of Non-Compete Clauses

Non-compete clauses are a type of restraint of trade, or a restrictive covenant. They are designed to prevent a former employee from engaging in activities that may compete with their former employer for a specific duration, within a certain geographic scope, or in relation to certain clients or business sectors. Such clauses often come into play in high-level roles where proprietary information, trade secrets, or sensitive customer relationships are involved.

While commonly included in employment contracts, it cannot be assumed that all non-compete clauses or restrictive covenants will ultimately be enforceable against the former employee. 

When Restrictive Covenants are Enforceable

A restrictive covenant is enforceable if: (a) it protects a legitimate interest of the employer, (b) it is reasonable in the interests of the parties, and (c) it is reasonable in the public interest.2

Restrictive covenants in the employment context are scrutinised more strictly that in other contexts. 

  1. Legitimate Interests of the Parties

Nonetheless, the Singapore Court has recognised three legitimate interests which an employer commonly seeks to protect through restrictive covenants, which includes: 

  1. its interest in protecting trade secrets or confidential information akin to trade secrets; 
  1. its interest in protecting trade connection (primarily clients or customers but presumably including trade connection with suppliers); and 
  1. its interest in maintaining a stable, trained workforce.3 

In determining whether an employer’s trade connection with its clients is a sufficient legitimate interest, it must be shown that the employee has personal knowledge of, and influence over, the employer’s clients4. Factors which the Court will take into consideration include5:

  1. the extent of the former employee’s knowledge of, and influence over, the clients in so far as it indicates the actual or likely future influence of the former employee over the clients’ decision as to where to direct their business;
  1. the frequency of the former employee’s contact with the clients; 
  1. the seniority of the former employee; and 
  1. the nature of the former employee’s relationship with the clients.

Protecting legitimate interests are critical in industries like finance, technology, law, or pharmaceuticals, where client retention and confidential processes are extremely valuable assets. However, when the clause simply attempts to stifle competition or control an employee’s future employment options without protecting specific business assets, courts tend to strike it down. Singapore’s judiciary has made it clear that the balance must tilt toward allowing individuals to earn a living, especially when no confidential information or client poaching is at risk.

  1. Reasonable in the Interests of the Parties

The restrictive covenant must be reasonable in scope, duration, and geographic reach. For example, attempting to enforce a two-year global non-compete clause on a mid-level marketing executive with limited access to confidential data would likely fail the test of reasonableness.

Similarly, a clause barring an employee from working in any capacity in a related industry, regardless of the specific nature of their new role, would likely be considered excessive. 

Further, blanket bans covering entire countries or continents are unlikely to be upheld unless the business operates at that scale and the employee held a correspondingly influential position.

The reasonableness of any restrictive covenant is a factual inquiry that varies between each case.

Ultimately, it is important to remember that where the legitimate interest to be protected is trade connection, the purpose of the protection under the law is to prevent the departing employee from relying on his trade connection to draw custom away for a reasonable period of time. The restraint ought not, therefore, to last longer than reasonably necessary to allow the employer the breathing space it needs, free of active interference with its trade connection from the departing employee, to transfer that trade connection to its other employees.6 

What constitutes a reasonable period or length of time depends on the strength and persistence of the trade connection and the time it takes to build and cement a new trade connection. That in turn will depend on the particular industry involved, the life cycle of trade connection in that industry and the role of the departing employee in the employer’s business7. All of this will need to be shown through evidence submitted to the Court.

  1. Reasonable in the public interest

Under this third requirement, the Court considers the impact of the restrictive covenant on local circumstances in determining whether it would be reasonable in the interests of the public.8 As an example, it would not be reasonable to uphold a restrictive covenant which would result in the creation of a monopoly.

Non-Compete vs. Other Restrictive Covenants

Non-compete clauses often appear alongside other restrictive covenants such as non-solicitation and non-disclosure clauses. Generally speaking, non-solicitation and confidentiality clauses are more regularly enforced than non-compete clauses. While the former can be narrowly tailored to protect specific relationships or sensitive information, the latter types of clauses inherently limit broader employment rights.

When possible, employers are encouraged to rely on these narrower restrictions, which are more palatable to the courts and less likely to be deemed unenforceable. Some companies use layered approaches, where non-solicitation or confidentiality clauses are backed by a more limited non-compete clause to cover the rare scenario of direct competition.

Drafting Enforceable Non-Compete Clauses

Employers aiming to include non-compete clauses in employment contracts must be precise and proportionate. A well-drafted clause will:

  • Clearly identify the business interest being protected.
  • Specify a time period that aligns with the risk posed by the departing employee.
  • Limit the geographic scope to the actual operational range of the company.
  • Define the restricted activities with enough clarity to avoid ambiguity.

Courts are more likely to uphold a clause that demonstrates thoughtfulness in its drafting rather than one that appears to be a generic template applied indiscriminately.

Employers who find themselves facing a situation where a former employee breaches any restrictive covenants (whether non-solicitation, non-compete or non-disclosure), the employer may have recourse to various legal remedies including seeking injunctions in a timely and urgent manner to prevent further breaches, and potentially claim damages.

Implications for Employees

Signing an employment contract with a non-compete clause should never be approached casually. Seeking legal advice on non-compete clauses in Singapore is particularly important for professionals in roles that deal with confidential business strategies, proprietary systems, or sensitive client information. A clear understanding of how the Courts view these non-compete clauses can empower employees to negotiate fairer terms from the outset and reduce the likelihood of future legal conflicts.

For individuals already bound by such a clause who believe it may be unreasonable or unenforceable, it is possible to apply for a legal review or court declaration challenging its validity. However, this route can be costly and time-consuming, with no guaranteed outcome. 

 The reported Court decisions in Singapore regularly highlight the necessity of drafting clear, focused, and justifiable terms. Whether you are an employer or an employee, it is advisable to proactively seek legal consultation before entering into any contracts or agreements, which may be more cost-effective in the long run and the larger scheme of things, for all parties involved.

  1. Guy Carpenter & Co Pte Ltd v Choi Okmi and others [2025] SGHC 241 at [1] (“Guy Carpenter”).
    ↩︎
  2. Lek Gwee Noi v Humming Flowers & Gifts Pte Ltd [2014] 3 SLR 27 at [34] (“Lek Gwee Noi”), citing Man Financial (S) Pte Ltd v Wong Bark Chuan David [2008] 1 SLR(R) 663 (“Man Financial”) at [70].
    ↩︎
  3. Lek Gwee Noi at [58], citing Man Financial at [81], [121]. ↩︎
  4. Guy Carpenter at [125]. ↩︎
  5. Guy Carpenter at [125], citing Lek Gwee Noi at [74]. ↩︎
  6. Guy Carpenter at [129], citing Lek Gwee Noi at [114]. ↩︎
  7. Guy Carpenter at [129], citing Lek Gwee Noi at [114]. ↩︎
  8. Tan Kok Yong Steve v Itochu Singapore Pte Ltd [2018] SGHC 85 at [89], citing Man Financial at [77] ↩︎

How to Handle Constructive Dismissal

When Resignation Isn’t Truly Voluntary

Resignation is typically seen as a voluntary act—one an employee initiates to take up better job opportunities or to deal with personal circumstances. However, in certain situations, an employee may feel compelled to resign because of an intolerable or hostile work environment or unbearable work conditions. 

This could mean having to face unreasonable treatment, harassment, bullying or discrimination in a hostile work environment, or being pressured to accept significant changes to fundamental or essential terms of their employment contract such that the job that they had agreed to perform has been changed materially (for example, expanded scope of work, reduced salary and change in working conditions). 

A resignation which occurs in these circumstances cannot be said to be voluntary, and it is referred to as “constructive dismissal.” 

The concept of “constructive dismissal” is grounded in the principle that an employer must not fundamentally breach the terms of the employment agreement. When that happens, the law may consider that the employer has effectively dismissed the employee without formally doing so.

 To succeed in a claim for constructive dismissal, the employee must establish that the employer had committed a fundamental breach of contract amounting to a repudiation (i.e. a repudiatory breach) of the employment agreement. 

It is not enough for the situation to be unpleasant; the actions or omissions by the employer must amount to a serious contractual violation which is sufficient to justify immediate resignation. Further, the employee must have accepted the repudiatory breach, and the said breach must have caused the employee to leave his or her employment.

It is important to distinguish between constructive dismissal and other forms of wrongful dismissal. Dismissing an employee without just or sufficient cause is wrongful. The Tripartite Guidelines on Wrongful Dismissal provides illustrations to guide employers and employees alike on what constitutes dismissals which are wrongful and not wrongful. Constructive dismissal is unique in that the employer doesn’t issue the termination—the employee does. Yet a tribunal or Court will treat it as a dismissal if the conditions surrounding the resignation were legally unacceptable. 

Legal Remedies Available

If an employee successfully proves constructive dismissal, they can seek compensation (which requires an assessment of damages) and even reinstatement in the employee’s former employment. However, reinstatement only occurs in rare and exceptional cases, because by the time legal proceedings are commenced, the working relationship between the employee and his or her former employer would have broken down already.

Filing a claim with the Tripartite Alliance for Dispute Management (“TADM”) is often the first step for employees pursuing a claim of constructive dismissal. A professional mediator from TADM will facilitate the mediation between the employee and employer. If the dispute remains unresolved, the employee can choose to escalate the case to the Employment Claims Tribunal (“ECT”).

A party dissatisfied with the decision of the ECT may appeal against the decision / order to the General Division of the High Court under specific circumstances. 

Parties cannot be represented by lawyers in the TADM mediation sessions, or in the ECT proceedings. However, they can seek legal advice on the procedure and the material to be submitted on their behalf for the mediation and to the tribunal. There are also specific timeframes when employees need to file their claims, so it is highly recommended that employees seek advice as early as possible after the last day of employment (or even before that, if possible). 

If your claim exceeds S$20,000 (or S$30,000 if you have gone through TADM mediation), or have a claim against a party who has a registered office or place of business outside Singapore, your claim cannot be brought to the ECT. Professional legal advice is strongly recommended, especially in cases involving senior roles or complex contractual arrangements which would exceed the jurisdiction of the ECT.

Practical Tips for Employers to Avoid Constructive Dismissal Claims

Employees who suspect they are being subjected to involuntary resignation, and who wish to pursue a claim in constructive dismissal should not rush to resign, without first gathering clear documentation which help to show that it is the employer’s conduct and actions that led to the resignation. This includes all emails, or other written correspondence via WhatsApp or other messaging platforms and applications which may support such a claim. Keeping a contemporaneous record of incidents that have contributed to the employer’s breach of contract is also critical to building a strong claim.

Before taking formal action, it may be beneficial to raise concerns with HR or management in writing. This demonstrates that the employee attempted to resolve the issue internally, which can be advantageous should the matter proceed to a tribunal or court.

Seeking legal advice early allows the employee to assess whether the employer’s conduct truly amounts to a fundamental breach. It also enables strategic decision-making about how and when to resign to preserve potential claims. A delay in resignation could be interpreted as acceptance of the new terms or conditions, thereby weakening the case for constructive dismissal.

From the employer’s perspective, in order to minimise the risk of facing claims in either wrongful or constructive dismissal, compliance with the Tripartite Guidelines  on Fair Employment Practices, addressing employees concerns in a genuine manner through proper channels and reviewing and improving HR policies and dismissal procedures are recommended. Employers who prioritize these responsibilities are better positioned to defend against claims that could arise from perceived breaches of contract.

Proactive measures—such as providing clear, written communication during workplace restructuring, issuing formal notices for changes in job scope or performance expectations, and following structured conflict resolution protocols—are essential. Maintaining detailed records and aligning all actions with established HR policies and employment law compliance standards strengthens an employer’s position should any dispute escalate to mediation or litigation. 

Whether you are an employee faced with a potential dispute with your employer, or if you are a business seeking guidance, we have experienced employment lawyers who can offer you valuable assistance.